Confidential consultations. Same-day appointments. 3110 N. Central Ave., Suite D-160, Phoenix, AZ 85012 (623) 777-3346
Evidence and procedure · A.R.S. § 13-1420

Evidence of Other Sexual Acts in Sex Crime Trials

Yes, a jury in an Arizona sex crime trial can sometimes hear about other sexual acts. Under A.R.S. § 13-1420, when a defendant is charged with a listed sexual offense, the court may admit evidence that the defendant committed past acts that would constitute a sexual offense, on any matter to which it is relevant.

Statute A.R.S. § 13-1420 Reviewed by Michael Tamou, attorneyReviewed November 15, 2026
The legal definition

What does A.R.S. § 13-1420 say?

A.R.S. § 13-1420 provides that when a defendant is charged with a sexual offense, the court may admit evidence that the defendant committed past acts that would constitute a sexual offense and may consider that evidence on any matter to which it is relevant. Sexual offense is defined by a specific list of crimes.

Read A.R.S. § 13-1420 in full
In plain English

What that means

In plain terms, if you are charged with one of the sex crimes on this law's list, the judge is allowed to let the jury hear about other sexual acts you are accused of committing in the past. Those acts do not have to have ended in a conviction, because the law speaks of acts, not convictions. The judge may allow it but is not required to, so the question is decided case by case.

If you are charged with a sex offense in Phoenix and there is another accusation in your past, even one that never led to charges, the jury may be allowed to hear about it. Under A.R.S. § 13-1420, when a person is charged with a listed sexual offense, the judge may admit evidence that the person committed other acts that would also be a sexual offense. It is not automatic. The judge may admit the evidence but is not required to, and the question is argued before trial. This page explains how prior acts evidence in sex crime cases works and how it is challenged.

What does A.R.S. § 13-1420 allow?

Under A.R.S. § 13-1420, if the defendant is charged with a sexual offense, the court may admit evidence that the defendant committed past acts that would constitute a sexual offense. The court may consider that evidence on any matter to which it is relevant.

Three features of the text stand out. It is permissive: the court may admit the evidence, and nothing says it must. It speaks of acts, not convictions. And it is broad about purpose: the evidence may be considered on any matter to which it is relevant.

The statute also says it does not limit the admission of evidence under any court rule. In practice the court rule matters as much as the statute. Arizona Rule of Evidence 404(c) covers the same ground, borrows the statute’s list of sexual offenses, and sets out the findings a judge must make before a jury hears any of this evidence.

What must the judge find under Rule 404(c) before the jury hears it?

The Arizona Supreme Court explained the rule in State v. Aguilar (2004), a Maricopa County case in which one indictment joined sexual assault charges involving several women. Before admitting an other act to show that the defendant had a character trait giving rise to an aberrant sexual propensity to commit the charged offense, the trial judge must make three determinations:

  1. Clear and convincing evidence that the defendant committed the other act. This standard, higher than more likely than not, comes from State v. Terrazas (Arizona Supreme Court, 1997).
  2. A reasonable basis to infer the character trait. The other act must provide a reasonable basis to infer that the defendant had a character trait giving rise to an aberrant sexual propensity to commit the crime charged.
  3. Balancing. The value of the evidence must not be substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice, confusion of the issues, or the other factors in Rule 403. The judge must consider how remote the other act is, how similar or dissimilar it is, the strength of the evidence that the defendant committed it, how often such acts occurred, the surrounding circumstances, and relevant intervening events.

The judge must make specific findings on each of the three. In Aguilar the court said that requires more than repeating the language of the rule. It also reversed the convictions in that case. The accusations turned on whether the women consented, which is a question of credibility, and the trial judge had made the clear and convincing finding from a grand jury transcript and the lawyers’ arguments without hearing from the accusers or reading any prior testimony from them.

Three more rules follow from the same line of authority:

  • The jury must be instructed. Under Rule 404(c)(2), when other-act evidence is admitted the court must instruct the jury on its proper use. The comment to the rule, quoted in Aguilar, says that at a minimum the jury should be told that the evidence does not lessen the state’s burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt, and that it may not convict simply because it finds the defendant committed the other act or had the character trait.
  • An acquittal does not automatically keep the act out. In State v. Yonkman (Arizona Court of Appeals, 2013), the court held that an acquittal does not bar other-act evidence under Rule 404, because the judge applies a lower standard of proof than the earlier jury did. The court also said that when acquitted conduct is presented, the fact of the acquittal often becomes admissible, and that judges decide this case by case.
  • Charges outside the list fall under Rule 404(b). Rule 404(b) bars other-act evidence offered to prove character, but allows it for other purposes such as motive, intent, plan, identity, or absence of mistake. For that evidence the state must give notice no later than 45 days before the final trial setting, unless the judge allows a later time for good cause.

Which charges does the statute apply to?

The statute has its own definition of sexual offense. It is a specific list, not every crime with a sexual element.

Statute Offense
§ 13-1404 Sexual abuse
§ 13-1405 Sexual conduct with a minor
§ 13-1406 Sexual assault
Prior law Sexual assault of a spouse
§ 13-1410 Molestation of a child
§ 13-1417 Continuous sexual abuse of a child
§ 13-1418 Sexual misconduct by a behavioral health professional
§ 13-3552 Commercial sexual exploitation of a minor
§ 13-3553 Sexual exploitation of a minor

Charges that are not on this list, such as luring or indecent exposure, are not sexual offenses for purposes of § 13-1420. That does not end the question, because the statute leaves the court rules in place and the state may turn to Rule 404(b). It does mean the first step in any case is to check the charge against the list.

Who does this affect?

The statute affects anyone charged with a listed offense who has anything in the past that the state can describe as a sexual act. Possible sources include:

  • A prior conviction for a sexual offense.
  • A prior arrest or investigation that did not lead to charges.
  • A former partner, relative, or acquaintance who comes forward after hearing about the new case.
  • Other counts or other accusers in the same indictment, where the state wants each accusation to support the others.

The effect on a trial can be significant. A case that rests on one person’s word may look, to a jury, like a pattern. The ruling on this evidence can therefore shape how the case ends, including whether it goes to trial at all.

What people commonly get wrong about other-acts evidence

  • “Only a prior conviction can be used.” The statute refers to past acts that would constitute a sexual offense. An accusation that was never charged, or never reported at the time, can be offered.
  • “It applies in every sex case, and to anything in my past.” Both ends are limited by the same list. The current charge must be one of the nine listed offenses, and the past act must be one that would constitute a listed offense.
  • “If my charge is not on the list, the evidence stays out.” Not necessarily. Subsection B says the statute does not limit the admission of evidence under any court rule, so the state may still offer other-act evidence under Rule 404(b) for a purpose other than character.
  • “The same rule lets me bring up the accuser’s past.” It does not. The accuser’s sexual history is governed by a separate statute, A.R.S. § 13-1421, which allows evidence of specific prior sexual conduct only in listed categories and only after a judge rules on it. See our page on Arizona’s rape shield law.

Example: one accusation becomes two

This is a hypothetical example, not a real case. Suppose a man is charged in Maricopa County Superior Court with sexual abuse under § 13-1404, based on a co-worker’s report. During the investigation a former girlfriend tells detectives that he touched her sexually without her consent eight years ago. She never reported it, and he was never charged.

Sexual abuse is on the § 13-1420 list, and the earlier allegation describes an act that would constitute sexual abuse. The state may therefore ask the judge to let the former girlfriend testify at the trial about the co-worker. The judge may allow it only after making the Rule 404(c) findings, starting with clear and convincing evidence that the earlier act happened and was not consensual. Now change the charge to indecent exposure. That offense is not on the list, so § 13-1420 does not apply, although the state could still try to offer the evidence under Rule 404(b).

Limits on § 13-1420: when the statute does not apply

  • The charge must be on the list. If the charged offense is not one of the nine, § 13-1420 does not apply.
  • The past act must also qualify. It must be an act that would constitute a listed sexual offense. Conduct that is merely embarrassing, or that falls under an unlisted statute, does not qualify under § 13-1420.
  • Relevance is the statute’s own test. The evidence may be considered only on a matter to which it is relevant.
  • Admission is never required. The statute says the court may admit the evidence.

The text of the statute does not say how strongly the past act must be proved, it sets no time limit, and it does not mention acquittals. Rule 404(c) and the court decisions described above fill those gaps: the act must be proved by clear and convincing evidence, remoteness is one factor in the balancing and not a fixed cutoff, and an acquittal does not automatically bar the evidence.

How does this play out in a Phoenix case?

Felony sex crime charges from every Valley city are prosecuted by the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office and filed in Maricopa County Superior Court in downtown Phoenix. It does not matter whether the arrest was made by Phoenix, Chandler, Gilbert, Glendale, or the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office.

Other-acts evidence can surface in stages:

  1. Investigation. Detectives may look for earlier reports, former partners, and other possible accusers, and interview them.
  2. Disclosure. After the not guilty arraignment, the state discloses its evidence. Rule 15.1 of the Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure requires the state to give the defense a list of the defendant’s other acts it intends to use at trial, generally within 30 days after arraignment in superior court unless the court orders otherwise.
  3. Pretrial motions. The state asks the judge to admit the evidence, or the defense moves to exclude it. These motions are litigated in the pretrial phase, between the Initial Pretrial Conference and trial, and those dates are commonly moved. Rule 16.1(b) sets the general deadline for motions at 20 days before trial unless the judge changes it.
  4. Hearing and ruling. The judge decides whether the jury will hear the evidence, and in what form, and must put specific findings on the record.
  5. Trial. If the evidence comes in, the defense addresses it in front of the jury through cross-examination and argument.

What does a defense lawyer do about prior acts evidence in sex crime cases?

Because the statute says the court may admit the evidence, and Rule 404(c) requires findings first, there is always an argument that it should not come in. Beyond checking the limits above, the work includes:

  • Challenging whether the act happened. An uncharged accusation has never been tested, and the state must prove it by clear and convincing evidence. The defense can investigate it as a case of its own: timing, motive, inconsistencies, and contact between accusers. Where the question turns on credibility, Aguilar supports asking that the judge hear from the witness and not rule on a police summary.
  • Challenging relevance. The statute ties admission to a matter to which the evidence is relevant. An act that is remote in time or different in kind may have little bearing on the charge.
  • Arguing unfair prejudice. The judge must weigh the risk that a jury convicts because of the past, instead of the charge, against the value of the evidence. Remoteness, dissimilarity, and weak proof of the other act all count against admission.
  • Limiting the damage. If the evidence is admitted, the defense can ask the judge to narrow it. The judge must instruct the jury on how it may be used, and the defense can propose the wording.
  • Moving to sever counts. Where the state joins several accusers in one case only because the offenses are of the same or similar character, Rule 13.4(b) of the Rules of Criminal Procedure entitles the defendant to separate trials unless evidence of the other offenses would be admissible if they were tried separately. That makes the Rule 404(c) ruling decisive. A motion to sever must be made at least 20 days before trial and renewed during trial.

Our attorneys retain experts where the case calls for them. When the other act rests on a child’s statement, that can mean forensic interviewing and memory experts. A psychosexual evaluation may also be obtained. Its purpose is a written report by a qualified evaluator that can show the accused is not sexually interested in the ages or the behavior alleged and is not the kind of person who acts that way. It may include a polygraph. The defense can use the report in negotiations with the prosecutor and at sentencing.

An evaluation can also bear on the Rule 404(c) question itself, with a cost. In State v. LaBianca (Pedro) (Arizona Court of Appeals, 2022), a Maricopa County defendant gave notice that a psychologist who had examined him would testify at the Rule 404(c) hearing that he found no paraphilia. The court held that if the judge allows that testimony, the judge must also allow the state’s expert to examine the defendant on request, with limits on how the state may use what he says. The court also noted that the state does not have to prove the character trait itself, only a reasonable basis to infer it. Whether to offer an evaluation at that hearing is a decision to make with a lawyer.

What to do next if there is something in your past the state might use

  1. Do not speak with police without a lawyer. That includes questions about earlier relationships or old accusations.
  2. Do not contact any accuser. That includes a former partner or relative who may become a witness.
  3. Do not delete anything. Keep old messages, photos and social media accounts as they are.
  4. Gather and keep documents. Collect anything from an earlier investigation or case: police report numbers, court records, and any paperwork showing how it ended.
  5. Tell your lawyer everything in your past, including matters that were never reported. Your lawyer can only prepare for what he or she knows about.
  6. Call for a free, confidential consultation at (623) 777-3346. Arizona Sex Crime Lawyers defends only people accused of sexual offenses. The firm’s attorneys include former prosecutors, former law enforcement officers, and former public defenders, led by Michael Tamou.

Frequently asked questions

Can the jury hear about an accusation I was never charged with?

It is possible. A.R.S. § 13-1420 refers to past acts that would constitute a sexual offense, and it does not require a conviction. The judge decides before trial whether a particular accusation will be admitted.

Does the statute apply if my prior case ended in an acquittal or dismissal?

The text of § 13-1420 does not address acquittals or dismissals. In State v. Yonkman (2013), the Arizona Court of Appeals held that an acquittal does not bar other-act evidence under Rule 404, because the judge decides by clear and convincing evidence, a lower standard than proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The defense can still contest the findings and ask that the jury be told about the acquittal.

Can an act from decades ago be used?

The text of § 13-1420 sets no time limit on the past act, and Rule 404(c) has no fixed cutoff. Remoteness is one of the factors the judge must weigh, so an old and dissimilar act is harder for the state to get admitted than a recent and similar one.

Does this apply to non-sexual prior convictions?

No. Section 13-1420 covers only past acts that would constitute a sexual offense on its list. Other kinds of prior acts are governed by the general rules of evidence.

Can prior acts evidence be used to get a plea instead of a trial?

It can shape negotiations. When a judge rules that other acts will be admitted, the state’s position gets stronger, and when the evidence is excluded, it gets weaker. That is why the pretrial motion can be one of the most important hearings in the case.

Sources

  • A.R.S. § 13-1420: what the court may admit, the any-relevant-matter language, the court rules clause, and the list of nine sexual offenses
  • A.R.S. § 13-1421: the separate statute that limits evidence of the accuser’s prior sexual conduct
  • State v. Aguilar, 209 Ariz. 40 (Arizona Supreme Court 2004): the text of Rule 404(c), the three required determinations, the specific findings requirement, the jury instruction, and severance under Rule 13.4(b)
  • State v. Terrazas, 189 Ariz. 580 (Arizona Supreme Court 1997): other acts must be proved by clear and convincing evidence
  • State v. Yonkman, 233 Ariz. 369 (Arizona Court of Appeals 2013): acquitted conduct and evidence of the acquittal
  • State v. LaBianca (Pedro), No. 1 CA-SA 22-0157 (Arizona Court of Appeals 2022): defense psychosexual evidence at a Rule 404(c) hearing and the state’s right to its own examination
  • Arizona Rule of Evidence 404(b) (Arizona Supreme Court order R-20-0011, effective January 1, 2021): permitted uses of other-act evidence and the 45-day notice requirement
  • Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure 13.3, 13.4, 15.1 and 16.1 (Arizona Supreme Court order R-17-0002, effective January 1, 2018): joinder, severance, disclosure of other acts, and the motion deadline
Confidential case review

Speak with an attorney, in confidence.

An attorney of the firm will review what you send and respond by the method you choose.

Office
3110 N. Central Ave., Suite D-160
Phoenix, Arizona 85012
Consultation
Without charge. Same-day appointments are usually available.
Discretion
No voicemail or email from the firm will state the reason for the contact.
Request a reviewConfidential

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Call (623) 777-3346 Case Review