What does A.R.S. § 13-1421 say?
A.R.S. § 13-1421 bars reputation and opinion evidence about a victim's chastity in Arizona sex crime prosecutions. Evidence of specific instances of the victim's prior sexual conduct may be admitted only if a judge finds it relevant, material, not outweighed by its prejudicial nature, and within one of five listed categories.
Read A.R.S. § 13-1421 in fullWhat that means
In plain terms, this law limits what a jury may hear about the sexual past of the person making the accusation. Evidence of that person's reputation for chastity, or opinions about it, is never allowed. Specific past events can come in only in five situations, such as a past sexual relationship with the accused or an earlier false accusation against someone else, and only after a judge holds a hearing and approves it first.
The rape shield law in Arizona, A.R.S. § 13-1421, limits what a jury may hear about an accuser’s sexual history. Evidence of the accuser’s reputation for chastity, and opinions about it, is never admissible. Specific past sexual conduct can be admitted only if it fits one of five categories, the judge makes required findings, and the court orders it admitted after a hearing on a written motion. For a person charged in Phoenix, those five categories can be central to the defense, and the motion is litigated before trial in Maricopa County Superior Court.
What does the rape shield law in Arizona do?
Section 13-1421 sets two rules.
- Reputation and opinion evidence is out. Evidence of a victim’s reputation for chastity, and opinion evidence about a victim’s chastity, is inadmissible. There are no exceptions to this part in the statute.
- Specific instances are limited. Evidence of specific instances of the victim’s prior sexual conduct may be admitted only if a judge finds that the evidence is relevant, is material to a fact in issue, is not outweighed by its inflammatory or prejudicial nature, and fits one of five categories.
The effect is to keep a trial focused on the charged incident, not on the accuser’s private life, while leaving room for evidence that bears directly on whether the accusation is true.
Which cases does A.R.S. § 13-1421 apply to?
The statute applies in any prosecution under:
- chapter 14 of the criminal code, the sexual offenses chapter, which includes sexual assault, sexual abuse, sexual conduct with a minor, and molestation of a child,
- A.R.S. § 13-3212, child sex trafficking, and
- chapter 35.1, the sexual exploitation of children chapter.
What are the five exceptions?
Evidence of specific instances of the victim’s prior sexual conduct may be admitted if it meets the judge’s findings and is one of the following:
- Evidence of the victim’s past sexual conduct with the defendant.
- Evidence of specific instances of sexual activity showing the source or origin of semen, pregnancy, disease, or physical injury.
- Evidence that supports a claim that the victim has a motive in accusing the defendant of the crime.
- Evidence offered for impeachment, meaning to challenge a witness’s credibility, when the prosecutor puts the victim’s prior sexual conduct in issue.
- Evidence of false allegations of sexual misconduct made by the victim against others.
What is allowed and what is not: a comparison
| Type of evidence | Treatment under § 13-1421 |
|---|---|
| The accuser’s reputation for chastity | Inadmissible |
| A witness’s opinion about the accuser’s chastity | Inadmissible |
| Past sexual conduct between the accuser and the defendant | May be admitted after a hearing and court order |
| Sexual activity that explains semen, pregnancy, disease, or physical injury | May be admitted after a hearing and court order |
| Evidence of a motive to accuse the defendant | May be admitted after a hearing and court order |
| Impeachment after the prosecutor raises prior sexual conduct | May be admitted after a hearing and court order |
| False allegations of sexual misconduct against others | May be admitted after a hearing and court order |
| Other specific instances of prior sexual conduct | Not admissible under the statute |
How does the pretrial hearing work?
The statute sets a procedure, and skipping it can cost the defense the evidence entirely.
- Written motion. The side that wants to use the evidence files a written motion. This is usually the defense.
- Hearing. The court holds a hearing on the written motions before the evidence can be used.
- Standard. The standard for admissibility is clear and convincing evidence. That is a demanding standard of proof, generally described as higher than “more likely than not” and lower than “beyond a reasonable doubt”. In State ex rel. Montgomery v. Padilla, 238 Ariz. 560 (App. 2015), the Arizona Court of Appeals said the side offering the evidence must prove three things to that standard: that the evidence is relevant and material to a fact in issue, that it is one of the five listed kinds, and that its inflammatory or prejudicial nature does not outweigh its probative value.
- Court order. The evidence may not be referred to in any statement to the jury or introduced at trial without a court order.
If new information is discovered during the trial that may make the evidence admissible, the statute lets the court hold a hearing at that point.
Section 13-1421 sets no filing deadline of its own. The general rule for pretrial motions, Rule 16.1(b) of the Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure, says motions must be made no later than 20 days before trial and lets the judge change motion deadlines. Under Rule 16.1(c), a judge may refuse to hear a motion that was not raised on time, unless its basis was not known and could not have been known earlier through reasonable diligence.
An example of how the rule applies
This is a hypothetical example, not a real case. Suppose a man is charged with sexual assault. His lawyer learns two things. First, a former coworker is willing to say the accuser “has a reputation”. Second, the accuser reported a different man to police two years earlier and later told the detective that report was not true. The coworker’s testimony is reputation evidence, and § 13-1421 bars it with no exception. The earlier report is different. It falls within the fifth category, false allegations of sexual misconduct against others. To use it, the defense must file a written motion, prove the point by clear and convincing evidence at a hearing, and obtain the judge’s findings and order before mentioning it to the jury.
What have Arizona courts said about the rape shield law?
Two published Court of Appeals opinions show how judges apply the statute.
- The statute is constitutional, and each exclusion can still be tested. In State v. Gilfillan, 196 Ariz. 396 (App. 2000) (abrogated on other grounds by State v. Carson, 243 Ariz. 463 (2018)), the court said the law “clearly implicates” a defendant’s constitutional rights to the extent it keeps out relevant evidence, but that the right to present evidence is not limitless. It upheld the statute because it uses notice and a hearing instead of an automatic ban. The court also recognized that whether such a law may be applied to keep out particular evidence that helps the accused is examined case by case.
- A prior false allegation needs real proof of falsity. In Gilfillan, the defense offered a boy’s testimony that the accuser had falsely told a friend he tried to rape her. She denied saying it, the two accounts conflicted, and no one who heard the supposed accusation testified. The court upheld the ruling that falsity was not shown by clear and convincing evidence.
- Proof that an allegation was made is not proof that it was false. In State ex rel. Montgomery v. Padilla, the trial judge found clear evidence that a child had reported being touched by another person, but made no finding on whether the report was true or false. The Court of Appeals vacated the order admitting the evidence, because the fifth category requires a finding that the allegation was false. The same opinion noted that under A.R.S. § 13-4437(A) a victim may be represented by personal counsel in asserting victims’ rights, and it granted relief to the child’s representative, whose lawyer had not been allowed to argue in the pretrial proceedings.
What people commonly get wrong about the rape shield law
- “The accuser’s sexual history can never come in.” Reputation and opinion evidence cannot. Specific instances can, in the five listed categories.
- “If it fits an exception, the jury will hear it.” Fitting a category is not enough. The judge must also find the evidence relevant and material, and find that its inflammatory or prejudicial nature does not outweigh its probative value, meaning its usefulness in proving a fact.
- “The defense can simply ask about it on cross-examination.” The statute requires a written motion, a hearing, and a court order first.
- “It applies only to adult rape cases.” It applies to every prosecution in the sexual offenses chapter, the sexual exploitation of children chapter, and the child sex trafficking statute, including cases with child accusers.
- “It protects the accused’s history too.” Section 13-1421 addresses evidence about the victim. Evidence of the defendant’s other acts is governed by different rules, including A.R.S. § 13-1420.
Limits and conditions written into the statute
- The list of covered prosecutions is specific. The statute names chapter 14, § 13-3212, and chapter 35.1. It does not name other chapters.
- All of the judge’s findings are required. Relevance, materiality, the balance of prejudice against probative value, and one of the five categories must all be present.
- The impeachment category has a trigger. It applies when the prosecutor puts the victim’s prior sexual conduct in issue.
- Timing. The evidence may not be used until a hearing on written motions has been held. The statute separately allows a hearing during trial when new information is discovered that may make the evidence admissible.
How the rape shield law plays out in a Phoenix case
Felony sex crime charges from every Valley city are filed in Maricopa County Superior Court in downtown Phoenix. It does not matter whether Scottsdale, Mesa, Tempe, or Glendale police made the arrest. The rape shield motion is filed in that court, in the pretrial phase between the not guilty arraignment and trial, as the case moves through the Initial Pretrial Conference, the Comprehensive Pretrial Conference, and the Final Trial Management Conference. Those dates are commonly moved.
The prosecutor can oppose the motion, and the judge’s ruling can change the shape of the trial. If evidence of a prior false allegation or a motive to accuse comes in, the jury hears a fuller account. If it stays out, the defense has to be built without it. See also our page on evidence of other sexual acts in sex crime trials, which covers the rule that lets the state offer the defendant’s past acts.
What a defense lawyer does about the rape shield law
- Investigates early. Evidence for an exception has to be found before it can be offered: messages, medical records, prior police reports, and witnesses. This is done through lawful investigation and court process, never by contacting the accuser directly.
- Matches the evidence to a category. The statute admits only evidence that is one of the five listed kinds, so the motion has to tie each item to a category.
- Builds proof to the clear and convincing standard. For example, a claim of a prior false allegation needs evidence that the earlier allegation was made and was false, not only that no charge followed.
- Files the written motion and asks for the hearing. The statute requires both.
- Raises constitutional arguments. An accused person has constitutional rights to confront witnesses and present a defense, and a lawyer can argue that those rights require the jury to hear the evidence.
- Follows the order at trial. Mentioning excluded evidence in front of the jury can lead to sanctions or a mistrial.
No lawyer can promise that a judge will admit a particular piece of evidence.
The rape shield motion is only one part of a defense. Our attorneys retain experts where the case calls for them, such as DNA and forensic nurse experts when the source of physical evidence is disputed. A psychosexual evaluation may also be obtained: an examination by a qualified evaluator, which may include a polygraph, that produces a written report. The report can show that the accused is not sexually interested in the ages or the behavior alleged and is not the kind of person who acts that way. The defense can use it in negotiations with the prosecutor and at sentencing.
What to do next if this evidence matters in your case
- Do not talk to police without a lawyer.
- Do not contact the accuser, and do not ask friends or family to ask the accuser, or people close to the accuser, about his or her past.
- Do not delete messages, photos, or accounts. Your own message history with the accuser may be the evidence of a prior relationship.
- Gather and keep what you already have. Write down for your lawyer what you know: the history between you and the accuser, the names of people with firsthand knowledge, and any earlier accusation you are aware of and how you learned of it.
- Tell your lawyer early. The motion has to be written, filed, and heard before trial. Arizona Sex Crime Lawyers defends only sex crime cases in Phoenix and the Valley. The firm’s attorneys include former prosecutors, former law enforcement officers, and former public defenders. Call (623) 777-3346 for a free, confidential consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Can the jury hear that the accuser and I had a prior sexual relationship?
Possibly. Past sexual conduct with the defendant is one of the five categories in A.R.S. § 13-1421. The judge must still find the evidence relevant, material, and not outweighed by its prejudicial nature, and must order it admitted after a hearing.
Can I show that the accuser made a false accusation against someone else?
Evidence of false allegations of sexual misconduct made by the victim against others is one of the listed categories. The standard for admissibility is clear and convincing evidence, so the defense needs solid proof that the earlier allegation was false.
Does the rape shield law apply when the accuser is a child?
Yes. The statute applies in any prosecution under the sexual offenses chapter, the sexual exploitation of children chapter, and the child sex trafficking statute, which cover offenses against minors.
What happens if this evidence is mentioned without a court order?
The statute says the evidence may not be referred to in front of the jury or introduced without a court order after a hearing on written motions. A violation can bring consequences from the judge, so the motion must be decided first.
Does the rape shield law limit evidence about me, the accused?
No. Section 13-1421 addresses evidence about the victim. Evidence about the defendant’s other acts is governed by different rules, including A.R.S. § 13-1420.
Sources
- A.R.S. § 13-1421: the bar on reputation and opinion evidence, the five categories, the judge’s required findings, the written motion and hearing, and the clear and convincing standard
- A.R.S. § 13-3212: the child sex trafficking statute, which § 13-1421 names as covered
- A.R.S. § 13-1420: the separate rule on evidence of the defendant’s other sexual acts
- State v. Gilfillan, 196 Ariz. 396 (Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One, 2000) (abrogated on other grounds by State v. Carson, 243 Ariz. 463 (2018)): the statute’s constitutionality and the proof needed for a prior false allegation
- State ex rel. Montgomery v. Padilla, 238 Ariz. 560 (Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One, 2015): what must be proved by clear and convincing evidence, the falsity finding, and the victim’s counsel
- A.R.S. § 13-4437: the victim’s right to be represented by personal counsel, as cited in Padilla
- Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 16.1 (Arizona Supreme Court order R-17-0002, effective January 1, 2018): the 20-day deadline for pretrial motions. Court rules are amended from time to time, so check the current rule