What does A.R.S. § 13-1416 say?
A.R.S. § 13-1416 says a statement by a minor under ten describing a sexual offense or physical abuse is admissible if a court finds it reliable and other conditions are met. In State v. Robinson (1987), the Arizona Supreme Court held the statute unconstitutional and directed courts to apply the rules of evidence instead.
Read A.R.S. § 13-1416 in fullWhat that means
In plain terms, a jury normally does not hear secondhand accounts of what someone said outside court. This statute tried to make an exception for a child under 10 who told someone about abuse. The Arizona Supreme Court struck it down in 1987. Today a judge decides if a child's statement comes in under the court's own evidence rules, such as the exceptions for excited statements and statements made for medical care.
If the case against you rests on what a child said, the first question is whether a jury will be allowed to hear it, and how. Four Arizona statutes address it, but Arizona appellate courts have held two of them unconstitutional. In a criminal trial today, whether a child’s out-of-court statement comes in is decided mainly under the Arizona Rules of Evidence and the right to confront witnesses. This matters because in many child sex cases there is no physical evidence and no adult witness: the case is what a child told a parent, a teacher, and an interviewer on video. Child hearsay in Arizona is argued before trial, and in a Phoenix case that happens in Maricopa County Superior Court.
Which Arizona statutes cover a child’s statements and testimony?
| Statute | What it covers | Who it applies to | Who asks for it | Status in criminal trials |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A.R.S. § 13-1416 | Out-of-court statements describing a sexual offense or physical abuse | A minor under 10 | The party offering the statement, with advance notice | Held unconstitutional in State v. Robinson (Arizona Supreme Court, 1987) |
| A.R.S. § 13-4252 | A recording of a minor’s oral statement made before the proceeding begins | A minor under 15, or a person with a developmental disability and a tested IQ below 75 | The party offering the recording | Held unconstitutional in State v. Taylor (Arizona Court of Appeals, 1999) |
| A.R.S. § 13-4253 | Testimony by closed circuit television, or recorded outside the courtroom | The same definition of minor | The prosecution, by motion | Can be used only on an individualized showing of necessity, State v. Vincent (Arizona Supreme Court, 1989) |
| A.R.S. § 13-4254 | A bar on direct questioning by a self-represented defendant | A minor victim in cases with listed sexual offense, child prostitution or sex trafficking, or child abuse charges | The prosecution, by motion | Not addressed in the decisions cited on this page |
The definition of minor for the last three statutes comes from A.R.S. § 13-4251.
What is child hearsay under A.R.S. § 13-1416?
Hearsay is a statement made outside court that is offered as proof of what it says. It is normally not allowed. As written, section 13-1416 makes an otherwise inadmissible statement by a minor under 10 admissible, in a criminal or civil proceeding, when the statement describes a sexual offense or physical abuse and these conditions are met:
- The court holds an in camera hearing, meaning a hearing outside the presence of the jury.
- The court finds that the time, content, and circumstances of the statement provide sufficient indicia of reliability, meaning signs that the statement can be trusted.
- The minor either testifies, or is unavailable as a witness and there is corroborative evidence, meaning other evidence that supports the statement.
- The party offering the statement gave the other side advance notice of its intent to offer the statement and the particulars of the statement.
The statute is still printed in the code, but it does not control a criminal trial. In State v. Robinson, 153 Ariz. 191 (1987), the Arizona Supreme Court found that the statute conflicts with the court’s own evidence rules and intrudes on the court’s constitutional authority to make procedural rules. The opinion states: “We therefore hold § 13-1416 unconstitutional. Henceforth, the admissibility of child hearsay statements should be determined under the rules of evidence.” So when a parent, relative, or teacher is called to repeat what a young child told them, the prosecutor has to fit the statement within an exception in the Arizona Rules of Evidence.
Which evidence rules decide whether a child’s statement comes in?
These are the exceptions in the Arizona Rules of Evidence that most directly fit a child’s statement to a parent, teacher, or medical provider:
- Excited utterance, Rule 803(2). A statement relating to a startling event or condition, made while the person was under the stress of excitement that it caused.
- Statement for medical diagnosis or treatment, Rule 803(4). A statement made for, and reasonably pertinent to, medical diagnosis or treatment that describes medical history, symptoms, their inception, or their general cause. Robinson applied a two-part test: whether the child’s apparent motive was consistent with receiving medical care, and whether it was reasonable for the physician to rely on the information in diagnosis or treatment. The court also held that, at least in child sexual abuse cases, a statement identifying the abuser can fall within this rule when identity is relevant to proper diagnosis and treatment.
- Residual exception, Rule 807. A statement not covered by another exception may be admitted if it has equivalent circumstantial guarantees of trustworthiness, is offered as evidence of a material fact, and is more probative on the point than any other evidence the party can obtain through reasonable efforts. The party offering it must give reasonable notice before trial of its intent to offer the statement and its particulars.
Each exception has its own conditions, and the defense can contest every one of them at a hearing before trial.
When can a recorded interview be played for the jury?
A child in a sex crime investigation may be interviewed on video early on. As written, section 13-4252 makes a recording of a minor’s oral statement, made before the proceeding begins, admissible if all eight of these conditions are met:
- No attorney for either party was present when the statement was made.
- The recording is both visual and aural.
- Every voice on the recording is identified.
- The person who conducted the interview is present at the proceeding and available to testify or be cross-examined by either party.
- The defense had an opportunity to view the recording.
- The minor is available to testify.
- The recording equipment was capable of making an accurate recording, the operator was competent, and the recording is accurate and has not been altered.
- The statement was not made in response to questioning calculated to lead the minor to make a particular statement.
Meeting those eight conditions is not enough in a criminal trial. In State v. Taylor, 196 Ariz. 584 (App. 1999), a molestation case in which a videotaped interview of an eight-year-old was played for the jury under this statute, the Arizona Court of Appeals held § 13-4252 unconstitutional for the same reason Robinson gave for § 13-1416: it “expands on, conflicts with, and engulfs the court’s rules.” The court said the admissibility of a minor’s hearsay statements should be determined by the rules of evidence and the rules of criminal procedure. It then found that the videotape did not qualify under the residual exception or any other rule, and it reversed the conviction because the recording had let the state present the child’s account twice.
The practical point is that a recorded interview is hearsay like any other out-of-court statement. The state must fit it within the evidence rules, and a recording that only repeats what the child says on the witness stand is generally not admissible to bolster that testimony. An interview full of leading or repeated questions, or one that follows earlier conversations with a parent, is also open to attack as untrustworthy.
Can a child testify outside the courtroom?
Yes, if the court orders it. Under 13-4253, on the prosecution’s motion, the court may order that a minor’s testimony be:
- taken in a room other than the courtroom and televised by closed circuit to the court and the jury, or
- taken outside the courtroom and recorded for showing in court.
The statute builds in protections for both sides. Only the attorneys may question the minor. The court must permit the defendant to observe and hear the testimony in person, while ensuring that the minor cannot hear or see the defendant. The defense still cross-examines. What changes is the room and the child’s view of the accused. A minor whose testimony is taken this way is not required to testify in court at that proceeding. Closed circuit means a live video feed from another room.
The statute itself lists no findings the court must make before granting the motion, but the Arizona Supreme Court has supplied one. In State v. Vincent, 159 Ariz. 418 (1989), the court reversed a conviction because children’s testimony had been videotaped outside the defendant’s presence with no particularized findings about those children. It held that § 13-4253 “requires the trial judge to condition the substitution of videotaped testimony for live testimony upon an individualized showing of necessity.” A general belief that testifying is hard on children is not enough. The defense can demand that showing and contest it.
What if the defendant has no lawyer?
Under 13-4254, on the prosecution’s motion, the court may prohibit a self-represented defendant from directly questioning the minor victim, if the court determines that direct questioning by the defendant would prevent the minor from being able to reasonably communicate. The statute applies to cases that include charges under chapters 14 and 35.1, and under A.R.S. § 13-3206, A.R.S. § 13-3212, or A.R.S. § 13-3623. The statute does not say how the questions are then asked.
What people often get wrong about a child’s statements
- “What the child told a parent is hearsay, so the jury will never hear it.” The hearsay rule has exceptions. A statement made in the stress of a startling event, a statement made to get medical care, or a statement that meets the residual exception can be admitted through the adult who heard it.
- “If the interview was recorded, the video replaces the child.” It does not. In State v. Taylor the court reversed a conviction because a videotaped interview was played in addition to the child’s testimony without fitting any evidence rule.
- “Closed circuit testimony means no cross-examination.” Under 13-4253 the attorneys for both sides question the minor, and the defendant must be allowed to observe and hear the testimony in person.
- “These rules cover any witness under 18.” The closed circuit statute defines a minor as a person under 15, or a person with a developmental disability and a tested IQ below 75. The evidence rules themselves have no age cutoff.
An example of how the statutes fit together
This is a hypothetical example, not a real case. Suppose a 7-year-old tells her aunt something that the state says describes molestation, and a week later a detective interviews the child on video. Because of Robinson and Taylor, the state cannot rely on § 13-1416 for the aunt or on § 13-4252 for the video. For the aunt to repeat the statement, the state would have to show, for example, that the child spoke while still under the stress of a startling event, or give notice and meet the residual exception. For the video, the state would need an evidence rule that fits a recorded interview made a week later, and Taylor shows how hard that can be when the child also testifies. If the state asked for the child to testify by closed circuit television, it would have to make an individualized showing that this child needs it.
Limits and conditions on these rules
- Two of the four statutes do not control criminal trials. Sections 13-1416 and 13-4252 remain in the code, but Robinson and Taylor held them unconstitutional. We found no later decision reviving either one. Their age cutoffs (under 10, and under 15) are part of statutes the courts do not apply in criminal trials.
- Closed circuit testimony needs a case-specific showing. Under Vincent, the court must find necessity for the particular child, not for child witnesses in general. The statute’s definition of minor, under 15 or the developmental disability definition, still applies.
- Who may ask. Closed circuit or recorded testimony, and the bar on questioning by a self-represented defendant, are ordered only on the prosecution’s motion.
- A required finding for self-represented defendants. The court must determine that direct questioning by the defendant would prevent the minor from being able to reasonably communicate.
- Confrontation still applies. Fitting a statement within an evidence rule does not end the analysis. The constitutional right to confront witnesses is a separate ground for objection, and how it applies depends on who the child was speaking to and why.
Who do these rules affect?
These statutes come up most in cases charged as molestation of a child, sexual conduct with a minor, and continuous sexual abuse of a child, where the child’s account is the center of the state’s evidence. They work alongside other evidence rules in sex cases, including the rape shield law and the rule on evidence of other sexual acts.
How this plays out in a Phoenix case
A report is made to a city police department in the Valley or to the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office. The child may be interviewed on video. The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office files charges, and the case goes to Maricopa County Superior Court in downtown Phoenix, whichever Valley city handled the arrest. The defense receives the recording and the reports during the pretrial stage, between the arraignment and the pretrial conferences.
Before trial, each side files motions about what the jury will hear. The defense asks for hearings, objects to statements that do not fit an evidence rule, and may ask the court to exclude a recording or parts of it. Those hearings take place without the jury.
What a defense lawyer does about a child’s statements
- Maps every statement. Who the child spoke to, in what order, and what each person said back. The first disclosure may not be the one on video.
- Tests reliability. How long after the event the child spoke, what words were used, who was present, and what prompted the statement all bear on whether an exception applies.
- Reviews the interview question by question. Leading, suggestive, or repeated questions go to whether the statement is trustworthy enough to be admitted, and to how much weight a jury should give it.
- Enforces notice. A statement offered under the residual exception without reasonable advance notice and particulars can be objected to.
- Holds the state to the rules. Robinson and Taylor mean the state cannot use § 13-1416 or § 13-4252 as a shortcut around the evidence rules.
- Protects confrontation. A request for closed circuit or recorded testimony can be opposed unless the state makes the individualized showing Vincent requires. If it is granted, the right to question the witness through counsel remains.
- Consults experts. Specialists in child interviewing and memory can review the recording.
Our attorneys also retain other experts where the case calls for them. One is a psychosexual evaluation. Its purpose is a written report, by a qualified evaluator, that can show the accused is not sexually interested in the ages or the behavior alleged and is not the kind of person who acts that way. It may include a polygraph. The defense can use the report in negotiations with the prosecutor and at sentencing. Many of these charges are alleged as dangerous crimes against children, and when a charge is alleged that way the sentencing exposure is severe, which is one reason that work can matter.
What to do next if your case depends on what a child said
- Do not speak with police without a lawyer.
- Do not contact the child or the child’s family, and do not ask anyone else to. Do not discuss the accusation with anyone but your lawyer.
- Do not delete anything. Keep messages, emails, and social media as they are.
- Gather and keep documents. Write down, from your own knowledge only, who the child may have spoken to and when. Keep custody and family court papers and messages with the other parent, which can bear on the circumstances of a statement.
- Call (623) 777-3346 for a free, confidential consultation. Arizona Sex Crime Lawyers defends only sex crime cases in the Phoenix area.
Frequently asked questions
Can a parent testify about what a child told them?
Only if an evidence rule allows it. The Arizona Supreme Court held A.R.S. § 13-1416 unconstitutional in State v. Robinson (1987) and said child hearsay is decided under the rules of evidence. The usual candidates are the exceptions for excited utterances, statements made for medical diagnosis or treatment, and the residual exception.
Does the child still have to testify if the interview was recorded?
A recording is not a substitute that keeps the child out of the case. In State v. Taylor (1999) the Court of Appeals held A.R.S. § 13-4252 unconstitutional and reversed a conviction where the video was played in addition to the child’s testimony. A recorded interview has to qualify under the evidence rules like any other out-of-court statement.
Will I be in the room when a child testifies by closed circuit television?
Not in the same room as the child. Only the attorneys, the equipment operators, and a person whose presence supports the child’s well-being may be in the room with the minor. The court must still permit the defendant to observe and hear the testimony in person, while ensuring the minor cannot see or hear the defendant, and only the attorneys ask the questions.
How old does a child have to be for these rules to apply?
The evidence rules that now decide hearsay questions have no age cutoff. The closed circuit statute, A.R.S. § 13-4253, applies to a person under 15, or a person with a developmental disability and a tested IQ below 75, and it requires an individualized showing of necessity.
Can the defense get a copy of the forensic interview?
The defense is entitled to review the state’s evidence, including a recorded interview, during the pretrial stage. Whether the defense receives a copy or reviews it under restrictions set by the court depends on the orders in the particular case.
Sources
Every legal statement on this page was checked against the official statute text published by the Arizona Legislature, the court rules, and the court decisions listed below. Statutes and rules change, so confirm the current version before relying on it.
- State v. Robinson, 153 Ariz. 191, 735 P.2d 801 (Arizona Supreme Court, 1987): § 13-1416 held unconstitutional, child hearsay decided under the rules of evidence, and the Rule 803(4) test for statements to a medical provider.
- State v. Taylor, 196 Ariz. 584, 2 P.3d 674 (Arizona Court of Appeals, 1999): § 13-4252 held unconstitutional, and a videotaped interview found inadmissible under the evidence rules.
- State v. Vincent, 159 Ariz. 418, 768 P.2d 150 (Arizona Supreme Court, 1989): § 13-4253 requires an individualized showing of necessity.
- Arizona Rules of Evidence, Rules 803(2), 803(4) and 807, as amended by Arizona Supreme Court Order R-10-0035: the excited utterance, medical diagnosis or treatment, and residual exceptions.
- A.R.S. § 13-1416: the text on a statement by a minor under 10, the reliability hearing, corroboration, and notice.
- A.R.S. § 13-4251: definition of minor and the proceedings the recording and closed circuit statutes apply to.
- A.R.S. § 13-4252: eight conditions for admitting a recorded statement and the right to call the minor.
- A.R.S. § 13-4253: closed circuit and recorded testimony, who may be present, and the defendant’s right to observe.
- A.R.S. § 13-4254: bar on direct questioning of a minor victim by a self-represented defendant.
- A.R.S. § 13-3206, A.R.S. § 13-3212, and A.R.S. § 13-3623: taking a child for prostitution, child sex trafficking, and child abuse, the offenses named in § 13-4254.