The defenses to a sexual assault charge under A.R.S. § 13-1406 are consent, fabrication, mistaken identity, that any incapacity was not known and could not reasonably have been known, and insufficient proof. Each one attacks an element the State must prove: an act of intercourse or oral sexual contact, done intentionally or knowingly, without consent.
What that means
In plain terms, the prosecutor has to prove that sex happened, that it was you, and that the other person did not agree or could not agree. A defense shows that one of those pieces is missing: the person said yes, the story is not true, police have the wrong person, or there was no way for you to know the other person was too impaired. The evidence decides which defense fits.
The defenses to a sexual assault charge in Arizona are consent, fabrication, mistaken identity, incapacity that was not known, and insufficient proof. Each one attacks something the State must prove under A.R.S. § 13-1406. If you or someone in your family is charged in the Valley, the real question is which of them the evidence supports. People searching for false accusations and possible defenses to rape and sexual assault may expect a list of loopholes. There are not many.
What does the State have to prove?
Under A.R.S. § 13-1406, a person commits sexual assault by intentionally or knowingly engaging in sexual intercourse or oral sexual contact with any person without that person’s consent. Three things, called elements, must each be proved beyond a reasonable doubt:
- An act of sexual intercourse or oral sexual contact, as those terms are defined in A.R.S. § 13-1401.
- That the defendant was the person who did it, and acted intentionally or knowingly.
- That the act was without consent.
Section 13-1401 says “without consent” includes four situations: the person was coerced by the immediate use or threatened use of force against a person or property; the person was incapable of consent because of a mental disorder, mental defect, drugs, alcohol, sleep, or a similar impairment, and that condition was known or should reasonably have been known to the defendant; the person was intentionally deceived about the nature of the act; or the person was intentionally deceived into believing the defendant was his or her spouse.
False accusations and possible defenses to rape and sexual assault: what is raised at trial?
| Defense | Element it attacks | Evidence that builds it |
|---|---|---|
| Consent | Without consent | Messages before and after, witnesses, video, conduct after the encounter |
| Fabrication | The act, or lack of consent | Motive, changing statements, prior false allegations, records that contradict the account |
| Mistaken identity | That the defendant did it | DNA, phone location data, alibi, the identification procedure |
| Incapacity not known | Known or should reasonably have been known | Toxicology, video and witness accounts of how the person appeared |
| Insufficient proof | Any element | Gaps, inconsistencies, missing testing, a weak investigation |
Consent
This can be the defense in cases between people who know each other. The act is admitted and the dispute is whether the other person agreed. The defense is built from the surrounding facts: what the messages say before and after, what bystanders saw, and whether the physical findings are consistent with consensual sex. Arizona’s rape shield law, A.R.S. § 13-1421, specifically lists evidence of the accuser’s past sexual conduct with the defendant as a category a judge may admit.
Fabrication
Here the defense is that the event did not happen, or did not happen as described. Jurors may want to know why someone would say it, so the defense may need to show a reason, such as a custody dispute, a breakup, or a need to explain something to a partner or parent. Section 13-1421 lists evidence supporting a claim that the accuser has a motive, and evidence of false allegations of sexual misconduct made against others, among the categories a judge may admit. The statute requires a written motion and a hearing before any of it is mentioned to the jury, and sets the standard at clear and convincing evidence.
Mistaken identity
Identity is more likely to be the issue when the people involved are strangers or the allegation is old. DNA can exclude a person as well as include one, and a DNA match proves contact, not the absence of consent. The defense examines how the identification was made, what the lab actually tested, and where the defendant’s phone was.
Incapacity that was not known
When the State’s theory is that the other person was too intoxicated or was asleep, it must also prove that the condition was known or should reasonably have been known to the defendant. Drinking is not the same as incapacity. A person can have no memory the next day and still have been walking, talking, and making decisions in a way that gave no sign of incapacity. Bar video, receipts, ride records, and witnesses who saw the person that night are the core of this defense.
A hypothetical example, not a real case. Suppose two coworkers leave a Scottsdale bar together, and the next morning one of them remembers nothing and reports an assault. Bar video shows her walking unaided, paying her tab, and ordering the ride. Her texts that night are coherent. The State must prove two things: that she was incapable of consent because of alcohol, and that her condition was known or should reasonably have been known to him. The video and texts bear on both. They do not decide the case. A jury does.
Insufficient proof
The defendant does not have to prove anything. Some cases are defended by showing that the State’s evidence does not add up: an account that changed between statements, evidence that was never tested, a timeline that does not work.
What do people get wrong about defending a sexual assault charge?
- “Consent is something I have to prove.” “Without consent” is part of the definition of the offense in § 13-1406. It is the State’s element to prove, not the defendant’s. Arizona’s definition of an affirmative defense in A.R.S. § 13-103 excludes any defense that denies an element of the offense, so a consent defense does not shift any burden to you.
- “There was no force, so there is no case.” Force is one of four situations § 13-1401 lists under “without consent.” Incapacity and two kinds of intentional deception are the others. Nothing in § 13-1406 requires a weapon or an injury.
- “Other accusations cannot come in if I was never convicted of them.” A.R.S. § 13-1420 speaks of past acts that would constitute a sexual offense, not past convictions. The limit is in the findings the judge must make first, described below.
What defenses does Arizona’s statute itself provide, and what are their limits?
Very few apply to sexual assault. A.R.S. § 13-1407 contains the statutory defenses to sex crime charges, and for a § 13-1406 prosecution the list is short:
- Emergency medical treatment. It is a defense that the act was done by a licensed physician or registered nurse, a person acting under their direction, or a person rendering emergency care at the scene, that it was a recognized and lawful form of treatment reasonably adapted to promoting the patient’s physical or mental health, and that it was administered in an emergency when the provider reasonably believed that no one competent to consent could be consulted and that a reasonable person would consent. Arizona generally requires a defendant to prove an affirmative defense, one that excuses conduct rather than denying an element, by a preponderance of the evidence under A.R.S. § 13-205, and the Arizona Supreme Court applied that rule to another § 13-1407 defense in State v. Holle (2016).
- Marriage is not a defense. The statute says it is not a defense to a sexual assault prosecution that the defendant was the spouse of the victim.
- Mistake of age and close-in-age defenses do not apply. Those subsections cover other offenses, such as sexual conduct with a minor, not sexual assault.
- Consent does not answer every charge. Where the other person is under 18, prosecutors may also charge sexual conduct with a minor under A.R.S. § 13-1405, an offense that has no consent element at all.
What can the State use to answer a defense?
Two things in particular. First, under § 13-1420, a court may admit evidence that the defendant committed past acts that would constitute a sexual offense. Testimony from another accuser can change a consent case, and the defense must be prepared to contest that evidence of other sexual acts before trial. In State v. Aguilar (2004), a Maricopa County case in which the defendant said the women consented, the Arizona Supreme Court held that Arizona Rule of Evidence 404(c) can apply to sexual assaults against adults. Before admitting the evidence, the judge must find by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant committed the other act, that it gives a reasonable basis to infer an aberrant sexual propensity, and that its value is not substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice. In a consent case, the court said, the question is whether the other contact was without consent, not simply whether it happened. The convictions in that case were reversed because those findings were not properly made. Second, the defendant’s own words in a police interview or a recorded call. A call recorded with the accuser’s consent falls within the exemption in A.R.S. § 13-3012 for a recording made with the consent of a party, so the defendant’s lack of consent does not make the recording unlawful.
Why does the choice of defense matter so much?
Because a conviction leaves the judge almost no room. Sexual assault is a class 2 felony, the second most serious felony class, and the statute bars probation. The first-offense range is 5.25 to 14 years, with a 7-year presumptive term, which is the starting point before aggravating or mitigating circumstances move it. Sentences for more than one sexual assault must run consecutively, meaning one after the other.
If the victim is under 15, sexual assault is punishable under A.R.S. § 13-705, the Dangerous Crimes Against Children statute, which applies to a defendant who is at least 18 or is tried as an adult. For a defendant 18 or older and a victim aged 12 or younger, subsection B requires life imprisonment with no release until 35 years are served (subsection B does not apply to masturbatory contact). In other cases, with no predicate felony, meaning a prior felony of a kind that statute lists, such as a sexual offense, subsection E sets 13 to 27 years with a 20-year presumptive term for a victim aged 12, 13, or 14, and subsection C allows a life sentence, or otherwise the same 13 to 27 year range, when the victim is under 12. Age 12 falls under subsection E only where subsection B does not apply, for example a defendant under 18 who is tried as an adult. When the accuser is 15 or older, § 13-705 does not apply.
How are these defenses built in a Maricopa County case?
Whichever Valley city’s police made the arrest, the case is filed by the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office in Maricopa County Superior Court in downtown Phoenix. After arrest there is an initial appearance within about a day. In Maricopa County almost everyone charged with a sex offense is given a bond; the main exception is a person who was on felony probation when arrested. The bond is usually high, and ankle monitoring is typically required. Other conditions, such as no contact with the accuser, may also be ordered. A defense lawyer can ask the judge to lower the bond or change the conditions. The County Attorney usually obtains an indictment, a formal charge issued by a grand jury. A not guilty arraignment follows, then a series of pretrial conferences and trial. Those dates are commonly moved.
The defense is built between arraignment and trial. That is when the motions that decide what the jury will hear are filed, including the rape shield motion and any challenge to other-acts evidence.
What do our attorneys do to build a defense?
The firm’s attorneys include former prosecutors, former law enforcement officers, and former public defenders, led by Michael Tamou. We retain specific experts where the case calls for them:
- DNA analysts to review the lab’s work and what the results do and do not show.
- Forensic nurse experts to review the medical examination. Findings may be consistent with consensual contact, and the absence of injury is itself evidence.
- Toxicologists to estimate alcohol levels and explain the difference between memory loss and incapacity.
- Digital forensic examiners and cell phone and location analysts to recover complete message threads and test the timeline.
In appropriate cases we also arrange a psychosexual evaluation. A qualified evaluator examines the client and prepares a written report. Its purpose is to show, where the facts support it, that the person is not sexually interested in the ages or the behavior alleged and is not the kind of person who acts that way. It may include a polygraph. No one can promise what a report will show, but a favorable report can be used in negotiations with the prosecutor and at sentencing. In a case where the statute requires prison on conviction, negotiations can matter a great deal.
What should you do to protect a defense?
Every defense above depends on evidence that can be lost early. Do not speak with police without a lawyer, because your own words can close off a defense. Do not contact the accuser. Do not delete anything, including messages that embarrass you. Save texts, receipts, and ride records, and write down who saw the two of you and where cameras might have been. Then call Arizona Sex Crime Lawyers at (623) 777-3346 for a free, confidential consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Is being drunk myself a defense to sexual assault?
No. Under A.R.S. § 13-503, temporary intoxication from voluntarily using alcohol or drugs is not a defense for any criminal act or required state of mind. The questions at trial remain whether the other person consented or was capable of consenting, and what you knew or reasonably should have known. Your own drinking may still be part of how the events are described, so discuss it with your lawyer rather than with anyone else.
Does the lack of injuries mean the case will be dismissed?
No. The statute does not require injury, and prosecutors may go forward without it. The absence of injury is still evidence, and a forensic nurse expert can explain to a jury what the findings are consistent with.
Can a prior relationship with the accuser be used as evidence?
It may be. A.R.S. § 13-1421 lists the accuser’s past sexual conduct with the defendant as a category a judge can admit, if it is relevant, material, and not outweighed by prejudice. It requires a written motion and a hearing before trial.
If the DNA matches me, is there any defense left?
Yes. DNA shows that contact occurred. It does not show whether the contact was consensual.
Do I have to testify to raise a consent defense?
No. A defendant cannot be required to testify, and consent can be shown through messages, witnesses, and cross-examination. Whether to testify is a decision made with your lawyer near the end of the trial, after the State’s evidence is in.
Sources
- A.R.S. § 13-1406: elements, felony class, prison terms, no probation, consecutive sentences.
- A.R.S. § 13-1401: definitions, including “without consent.”
- A.R.S. § 13-1407: the statutory defenses and which offenses each covers.
- A.R.S. § 13-1421: evidence of the accuser’s prior sexual conduct.
- A.R.S. § 13-1420: evidence of the defendant’s other sexual acts.
- A.R.S. § 13-3012: recording with one party’s consent.
- A.R.S. § 13-1405: sexual conduct with a minor.
- A.R.S. § 13-103 and A.R.S. § 13-205: definition of an affirmative defense and the defendant’s burden.
- A.R.S. § 13-503: voluntary intoxication is not a defense.
- State v. Aguilar, 209 Ariz. 40 (Ariz. 2004): Rule 404(c) findings in adult sexual assault cases where consent is claimed.
- State v. Holle, Arizona Supreme Court (2016): a § 13-1407 defense treated as an affirmative defense the defendant must prove.
- A.R.S. § 13-705: sentencing when the victim is under 15.