Confidential consultations. Same-day appointments. 3110 N. Central Ave., Suite D-160, Phoenix, AZ 85012 (623) 777-3346

Can a defendant win a sexual assault trial in Arizona?

Reviewed by Michael Tamou, attorneyReviewed November 15, 2026 Statute A.R.S. § 13-1406
Short answer

Yes. Defendants do win sexual assault trials in Arizona, because the State must prove every element of A.R.S. § 13-1406 beyond a reasonable doubt, including that the act was without consent. Acquittals happen when the evidence leaves real doubt. No lawyer can promise one, and a conviction requires prison.

In plain English

What that means

In plain terms, yes, people accused of rape are sometimes found not guilty. The prosecutor has to convince every juror, to a very high level of certainty, that it happened the way the accuser says. If the evidence leaves a real question, the jury is supposed to acquit. But a trial is a serious risk, because a guilty verdict means prison with no chance of probation.

Yes. Defendants do win sexual assault trials in Maricopa County Superior Court, because the State must prove every part of the charge beyond a reasonable doubt to a unanimous jury, and the defendant has to prove nothing. If you are asking how possible it is for a defendant to win a sexual assault case in Arizona, no one can honestly give you odds from the outside. The answer depends on evidence most people have not yet seen, and a loss means prison.

How possible is it for a defendant to win a sexual assault case in Arizona?

It is possible because of how the burden of proof works. The defendant is presumed innocent and does not have to prove anything, call any witness, or testify. The State must prove each element, meaning each fact that makes up the crime, beyond a reasonable doubt, and a jury’s guilty verdict must be unanimous. A juror who believes the accusation is probably true, but is left with a real doubt, is required to vote not guilty.

Every Arizona criminal jury hears the same instruction on this point, which the Arizona Supreme Court made mandatory in State v. Portillo (1995). Proof beyond a reasonable doubt is proof that leaves the juror “firmly convinced” of guilt, and if a juror thinks “there is a real possibility” that the defendant is not guilty, the juror must give the defendant the benefit of the doubt and find him not guilty. Under A.R.S. § 21-102, the jury has twelve members when the law authorizes a sentence of 30 years or more, and eight members otherwise. In either case, every juror must agree on the verdict.

Under A.R.S. § 13-1406, sexual assault is intentionally or knowingly engaging in sexual intercourse or oral sexual contact with any person without that person’s consent. In a consent case the act is not disputed, and the entire case is about the last three words. The definitions in A.R.S. § 13-1401 say “without consent” includes coercion by the immediate use or threatened use of force against a person or property, and incapacity from alcohol, drugs, sleep, or a similar impairment that was known or should reasonably have been known to the defendant. That second clause gives the State two things to prove in an intoxication case: that the person was incapable of consent, and that the defendant knew or should have known it.

What makes a sexual assault case triable?

A triable case is one where the defense can point to evidence, not just argument. These features generally matter:

  • The accuser’s account has changed. The first report, the forensic medical exam history, the detective’s interview, and later statements differ on points that matter.
  • Messages tell a different story. Texts before the encounter show interest, or texts afterward are friendly, with no sign that anything was wrong.
  • Independent witnesses or video. Bartenders, drivers, roommates, or cameras show how the two people were acting and how impaired anyone appeared.
  • The physical evidence is neutral. DNA confirms contact that the defendant never denied, and the medical findings are consistent with consensual sex.
  • A motive can be shown. A custody case, a relationship ending, or a need to explain something to another person.
  • The defendant said nothing harmful. There is no police interview and no recorded call in which the defendant apologized or changed his account. A call recorded with the accuser’s consent is exempt from Arizona’s interception law under A.R.S. § 13-3012, so the defendant’s lack of consent does not make the recording unlawful.
  • The investigation was thin. Witnesses were not interviewed, video was not collected, and testing was not done.

An example of a triable case

This is a hypothetical example, not a real case. Suppose the act is admitted and the State’s theory is that the accuser was too intoxicated to consent. She told the forensic nurse she had three drinks, and later told the detective she had eight. Her text the next morning says, “Had fun, call me.” The ride share driver remembers both of them talking normally. The defendant gave no statement. Each fact bears on the two things the State must prove: that she was incapable of consent, and that he knew or should have known it. Change one fact, so that he texted “I’m sorry, I should have stopped,” and the same case becomes much harder.

What makes a case hard to win?

The same list in reverse. It is better to know these before deciding anything.

Factor Helps the defense when Hurts the defense when
Defendant’s statements None were made, or they are consistent denials A police interview or recorded call contains an apology, an admission, or a changing story
Messages They show mutual interest and normal contact afterward They show the accuser saying no, or the defendant acknowledging it
Alcohol Video and witnesses show the accuser functioning normally Witnesses describe the accuser as unable to walk, speak, or stay awake
Physical findings No injury, or findings consistent with consensual contact Injuries that fit the accuser’s description of force
Prompt report The first account differs from later ones A consistent account given immediately to a neutral person
Other accusers None The court admits evidence of other sexual acts

The last row deserves attention. Under A.R.S. § 13-1420, a court may admit evidence that the defendant committed past acts that would constitute a sexual offense. If a second person is permitted to testify to a similar act, a consent defense can become much harder. Whether that evidence of other sexual acts comes in is decided by the judge, usually before trial, and it can be one of the most important rulings in the case.

What will the jury be allowed to hear?

Less than many defendants expect. Arizona’s rape shield law, A.R.S. § 13-1421, bars reputation and opinion evidence about the accuser’s chastity. Specific instances of prior sexual conduct are allowed only if the judge finds them relevant, material to a fact in issue, and not outweighed by their inflammatory or prejudicial nature, and only in listed categories, which include past sexual conduct with the defendant, evidence supporting a claim that the accuser has a motive, and false allegations of sexual misconduct made against others. The defense must file a written motion, win a hearing, and meet a clear and convincing standard before any of it is mentioned to the jury.

The practical point is that pretrial rulings can shape the trial. A defense that depends on evidence the judge has excluded is not a defense the jury will hear.

What do people get wrong about sexual assault trials?

  • “A DNA match decides the case.” Section 13-1406 has separate elements. DNA bears on whether the act happened. It says nothing about consent.
  • “No force means not guilty.” Force is only one of the situations § 13-1401 lists under “without consent.” Incapacity and intentional deception are also covered, and nothing in § 13-1406 requires a weapon or an injury.
  • “To win, I have to prove the accuser lied.” The defense has no burden. The jury instruction asks whether jurors are firmly convinced of guilt, not whether the accuser is lying, so a jury may acquit because a real doubt remains even if it believes the accuser is sincere.

What is at risk if the trial is lost?

Everything the statute provides. Sexual assault is a class 2 felony, the second most serious felony class, and the person convicted is not eligible for probation or a suspended sentence.

  1. A first offense carries a minimum of 5.25 years, a presumptive term of 7 years, and a maximum of 14 years. The presumptive term is the starting point, which the judge can move down or up for mitigating or aggravating circumstances.
  2. Each sexual assault sentence must run consecutively to, meaning after, any other sexual assault sentence. An indictment that charges separate acts as separate counts can produce stacked terms.
  3. A conviction requires registration under A.R.S. § 13-3821, and for most offenses the registration statute sets no end date. See sex offender registration in Arizona.

This is why the decision to go to trial is a weighing of risk, not a test of innocence. Some people with strong cases still choose a negotiated outcome, and some with difficult cases go to trial because the offer on the table is no better than the likely sentence. The decision belongs to the defendant, made with full knowledge of the evidence.

When is the risk higher than the first-offense range?

  • Prior felony convictions. Section 13-1406 sets 7 to 21 years with one historical prior felony conviction, and 14 to 28 years with two or more. A historical prior is an earlier felony that counts for sentencing under A.R.S. § 13-105.
  • A victim under 15. The offense is punishable under A.R.S. § 13-705, the Dangerous Crimes Against Children statute, where the terms are far longer. When the accuser is 15 or older, that statute does not apply.
  • A drug allegation. The statute adds three years to each term if the assault involved giving the person flunitrazepam, gamma hydroxy butyrate, or ketamine hydrochloride without the person’s knowledge.
  • Serious physical injury. If the assault involved the intentional or knowing infliction of serious physical injury, § 13-1406 allows a life sentence.
  • An accuser under 18. Prosecutors may also charge sexual conduct with a minor under A.R.S. § 13-1405, which has no consent element. Winning on consent does not answer that count.

How does a sexual assault trial work in Maricopa County?

It does not matter which Valley city’s police made the arrest. Felony sex crime cases are filed in Maricopa County Superior Court in downtown Phoenix, and the jurors are Maricopa County residents, who are required by state law to serve unless excused. After arrest there is an initial appearance within about a day. In Maricopa County almost everyone charged with a sex offense is given a bond; the main exception is a person who was on felony probation when arrested. The bond is usually high, and release typically comes with ankle monitoring and an order to have no contact with the accuser. A defense lawyer can ask the judge to lower the bond or change the conditions. The County Attorney usually obtains an indictment, a formal charge issued by a grand jury. A not guilty arraignment follows, then a series of pretrial conferences and trial. Those dates are commonly moved, and a trial date may be reset more than once.

In a consent case, the cross-examination of the accuser and the detective can be where the case is won or lost.

What do our attorneys do to prepare a case for trial?

The firm’s attorneys include former prosecutors, former law enforcement officers, and former public defenders, led by Michael Tamou. Trial preparation starts on the first day, not after negotiations fail. We collect every statement the accuser has made and chart the differences, interview witnesses the police did not, preserve video and records, and litigate the rape shield and other-acts motions.

We retain experts where the case calls for them. DNA analysts review the lab work. Forensic nurse experts review the medical examination and explain what the findings do and do not show. Toxicologists address alcohol levels, memory loss, and outward signs of impairment. Digital forensic examiners and cell phone and location analysts recover messages and test the timeline. Private polygraph examiners are used in appropriate cases.

In appropriate cases we also arrange a psychosexual evaluation. A qualified evaluator examines the client and prepares a written report. Its purpose is to show, where the facts support it, that the person is not sexually interested in the ages or the behavior alleged and is not the kind of person who acts that way. The evaluation may include a polygraph. No one can promise what a report will show, but a favorable report can be used in negotiations with the prosecutor and, if there is a conviction, at sentencing. A defendant who is ready for trial and holds a favorable report has two ways to a better result, not one. For the defenses themselves, see our page on statutory defenses to sex crime charges.

What should you do while deciding about trial?

Do not speak with police without a lawyer, do not contact the accuser directly or through anyone else, and do not delete anything. Gather the messages, receipts, and names of witnesses, including the ones you think hurt you, and keep them for your lawyer. Then call Arizona Sex Crime Lawyers at (623) 777-3346 for a free, confidential consultation about the strengths and risks of your own case.

Frequently asked questions

Can I be convicted on the accuser’s word alone?

Yes, if the jury believes that testimony beyond a reasonable doubt. The Arizona Supreme Court held in State v. Williams (1974) that a conviction may rest on the uncorroborated testimony of the victim of a sexual assault unless the story is physically impossible or so incredible that no reasonable person could believe it. That is why the consistency of the accuser’s statements, and anything that contradicts them, is the focus of the defense.

What happens if the jury cannot agree?

If jurors cannot reach a unanimous verdict, the judge may declare a mistrial. The United States Supreme Court held in Richardson v. United States (1984) that a mistrial after a hung jury does not end jeopardy, so the State may try the case again. Under Arizona Rule of Criminal Procedure 8.2(c), a new trial after a mistrial must begin within 60 days of the court’s order, unless that time is extended. The State may also offer a different resolution or dismiss. A hung jury is not an acquittal, but it can change how both sides view the case.

Should I testify at my own trial?

That is your decision, and it is made after the State’s evidence is in. Testifying lets the jury hear your account and also exposes you to cross-examination. If you choose not to testify, the United States Supreme Court held in Carter v. Kentucky (1981) that the judge must, on the defense’s request, instruct jurors that your silence cannot be used as an inference of guilt.

How long does it take for a case to reach trial?

It varies widely. Arizona Rule of Criminal Procedure 8.2 sets outer limits of 150 days after arraignment for a defendant in custody and 180 days for a defendant who is released, but Rule 8.4 excludes delays caused by or on behalf of the defense and continuances granted by the court, so in practice dates in Maricopa County Superior Court are commonly moved. Cases that involve forensic testing, expert witnesses, and pretrial motions take longer. Your lawyer can give a realistic estimate once the evidence has been reviewed.

Can the jury convict of a lesser charge instead?

Sometimes. Under Arizona Rule of Criminal Procedure 21.4, if either side asks and the evidence supports it, the court must give the jury verdict forms for offenses necessarily included in the charge and for an attempt. The jury cannot convict of an offense for which it was given no form. A case may also be resolved on a different charge by agreement before trial.

Can I ask for a judge to decide the case instead of a jury?

Only if the State and the court agree. Arizona Rule of Criminal Procedure 18.1(b) lets a defendant waive a jury if the State and the court consent, and the judge must first confirm in person that the waiver is knowing, voluntary, and intelligent. A.R.S. § 21-102(E) says the same about the parties and the court. Whether a bench trial is wise depends on the issues in the case and should be discussed with your lawyer.

Sources

Confidential case review

Speak with an attorney, in confidence.

An attorney of the firm will review what you send and respond by the method you choose.

Office
3110 N. Central Ave., Suite D-160
Phoenix, Arizona 85012
Consultation
Without charge. Same-day appointments are usually available.
Discretion
No voicemail or email from the firm will state the reason for the contact.
Request a reviewConfidential

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Call (623) 777-3346 Case Review