What does A.R.S. § 13-118 say?
A.R.S. § 13-118 allows a prosecutor, in a criminal case involving an offense other than a sexual offense, to file a special allegation of sexual motivation. The state must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that one of the purposes for which the defendant committed the crime was the defendant's sexual gratification.
Read A.R.S. § 13-118 in fullWhat that means
In plain terms, this lets a prosecutor claim that a crime that is not a sex crime on paper, such as a burglary or an assault, was committed at least partly for sexual reasons. It is not a separate charge. The state has to prove the claim beyond a reasonable doubt, and the jury or judge answers it separately. Under a separate law, a judge may then order sex offender registration.
If your charging document in Maricopa County includes a “sexual motivation” allegation next to a count that is not a sex crime, the prosecutor is using A.R.S. § 13-118. The sexual motivation allegation Arizona prosecutors can file claims that one of your purposes in committing the charged offense was your own sexual gratification. It is not a separate crime, and the state must prove it beyond a reasonable doubt. It matters because a finding lets the judge order sex offender registration for an offense that would not otherwise carry it.
What is the sexual motivation special allegation under A.R.S. § 13-118?
Section 13-118 lets the prosecutor file a special allegation of sexual motivation in any criminal case involving an offense other than a sexual offense, if sufficient admissible evidence supports it.
The statute defines the term. Sexual motivation means that one of the purposes for which the defendant committed the crime was the defendant’s sexual gratification.
The allegation does not carry its own felony class, and § 13-118 sets no prison term for it. It is a finding that is added to a conviction for something else.
What must the state prove?
The allegation has its own burden of proof and its own verdict. Under § 13-118:
- The prosecutor must have sufficient admissible evidence, meaning evidence a court would allow at trial, to justify the finding before filing the allegation.
- The state must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the offense with a sexual motivation.
- The trier of fact, meaning the jury in a jury trial or the judge in a bench trial (a trial without a jury), returns a special verdict, a separate finding, on the allegation.
State v. Harlow, 219 Ariz. 511 (App. 2008), shows how this works in practice. The indictment alleged that a burglary was committed “for the purpose of sexual gratification”, and the question went to the jury as an interrogatory, a written question, on the verdict form. The jury acquitted on burglary, convicted on the lesser offense of criminal trespass, and found sexual motivation on that lesser offense. The Arizona Court of Appeals affirmed, leaving in place the finding and the registration order that followed it.
What people commonly get wrong about the allegation
- “Nothing sexual happened, so it cannot apply.” The statute asks about purpose, not about contact. By its terms it applies to offenses that are not sexual offenses, when the state claims sexual gratification was a reason for the conduct.
- “Sexual gratification has to be the main reason.” The definition says “one of the purposes”. The state does not have to prove it was the only purpose or the primary one.
- “If I am convicted of the charge, the allegation comes with it.” The two questions are decided separately. A person can be convicted of the underlying offense and still win on the allegation.
- “A finding means automatic registration.” Under A.R.S. § 13-3821(C), the sentencing judge may require registration after a finding. The statute does not say the judge must.
An example of how the allegation is decided
This is a hypothetical example, not a real case. Suppose a man is charged with burglary for entering a neighbor’s home in Chandler and taking clothing. The prosecutor files a sexual motivation allegation, pointing to what was taken and to searches found on his phone.
At trial the jury answers two questions. First, is he guilty of burglary. Second, and separately, did the state prove beyond a reasonable doubt that one of his purposes was sexual gratification. If the jury convicts but answers no to the second question, there is no registration based on sexual motivation. If the jury answers yes, the judge then decides whether to order registration.
What kinds of cases does it affect?
The allegation is used when the state believes that conduct charged under a general criminal statute had a sexual purpose. The underlying charge might involve entering a home, following or contacting a person, restraining a person, or taking or recording something. Our page on kidnapping with intent to commit a sexual offense covers a related charge.
It also matters in plea negotiations. When a case that began as a sex offense is resolved with a plea to a different offense, whether the plea includes a sexual motivation finding can decide whether registration is on the table. In State v. Cruz, 252 Ariz. 411 (App. 2022), a man charged with sexual assault pleaded guilty to aggravated assault and admitted in the plea agreement that he acted for sexual gratification. The Court of Appeals held that the judge’s acceptance of that admission was a finding of sexual motivation under § 13-118, even though the state had not filed a separate special allegation, and that the conviction could not be set aside.
What happens if sexual motivation is found?
The main consequence is registration. Because registration after a finding is discretionary, there are two separate points at which the defense can contest it: the finding itself, and the judge’s decision whether to order registration once a finding is made.
| Situation | Registration under § 13-3821 |
|---|---|
| Conviction for an offense on the mandatory list in § 13-3821(A) | Required |
| Conviction for a non-listed offense with a sexual motivation finding | The judge may order it |
| Conviction for a non-listed offense with no sexual motivation finding, at trial or in a plea | No registration based on sexual motivation |
If registration is ordered, the duties are the same as for anyone else who must register. They include registering with the county sheriff, reporting in person every year during the month of the person’s birthdate, and registering online identifiers. Our pages on sex offender registration in Arizona and sex offender levels and community notification explain what follows. Not complying is a felony, covered on our page about failure to register as a sex offender.
Two other statutes attach consequences to the finding:
- No set-aside. Under A.R.S. § 13-905, the law that lets a court set aside a conviction after the sentence is completed does not apply to an offense with a sexual motivation finding.
- Civil commitment. Under A.R.S. § 36-3701, murder, assault, aggravated assault, unlawful imprisonment, kidnapping and first degree burglary count as sexually violent offenses for civil commitment purposes when the court determines beyond a reasonable doubt that the act was sexually motivated.
Limits and conditions on the allegation
- Not for sexual offenses. The allegation applies only to an offense other than a sexual offense. Section 13-118 does not define the term sexual offense. In State v. Cruz, the Court of Appeals described sexual assault and sexual conduct with a minor as crimes expressly listed as sexual offenses in the criminal code.
- Filing is the prosecutor’s choice. The statute says the prosecutor “may” file it, and only with sufficient admissible evidence.
- No deadline in the statute. Section 13-118 does not set a deadline for filing the allegation.
- No finding, no registration on this basis. Without a finding, § 13-3821(C) gives the judge nothing to act on for this purpose. The finding can come from a special verdict at trial or, as State v. Cruz held, from an admission of sexual motivation in a plea agreement that the judge accepts.
- Registration stays discretionary. Even with a finding, the judge decides.
How the allegation plays out in a Phoenix case
Cases are investigated by city police departments across the Valley and by the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office. The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office decides what to charge and whether to add the allegation. Felony charges of this kind from every Valley city are filed in Maricopa County Superior Court in downtown Phoenix. It does not matter whether the arrest was made in Tempe, Peoria, Chandler or Buckeye.
The usual sequence is the same as in other felony sex cases:
- Investigation and arrest.
- Initial appearance within about a day, where release conditions are set.
- A status conference and preliminary hearing, usually vacated (cancelled) because the County Attorney obtains an indictment, a formal charge issued by a grand jury.
- Not guilty arraignment.
- Initial Pretrial Conference, Comprehensive Pretrial Conference, Final Trial Management Conference and trial. Those dates are commonly moved.
The allegation can shape each stage. It may influence how the prosecutor describes the case when release conditions are argued, what evidence the state seeks, and what any plea offer contains.
What a defense lawyer does about a sexual motivation allegation
- Challenges the evidence of purpose. Sexual gratification is a state of mind. The state may try to prove it through circumstances, statements, internet history or items found in a search. Each of those can have an innocent explanation.
- Holds the state to admissible evidence. Material that would not be allowed at trial should not support the allegation.
- Contests the underlying charge. Without a conviction, there is nothing for the allegation to attach to. Identity, lack of intent, unlawful searches and unreliable statements are examined as in any other case.
- Asks for a no on the special verdict. The defense can ask jurors to reject the allegation even if they convict on the charge.
- Negotiates the allegation. In some cases, a resolution may be reached in which the allegation is not part of the plea. No result can be promised.
- Argues against registration. Evidence about the person and the offense can be presented at sentencing. That can include a psychosexual evaluation: an examination by a qualified evaluator, which may include a polygraph, that produces a written report. The report can show that the accused is not sexually interested in the ages or the behavior alleged and is not the kind of person who acts that way. The defense can use it in negotiations with the prosecutor and at sentencing.
What to do next if the allegation is on your paperwork
- Check every count. Look at the complaint or indictment for the words sexual motivation, the phrase “for the purpose of sexual gratification”, or a reference to § 13-118, and bring the paperwork to a lawyer. Read any plea offer for the same words.
- Do not speak with police without a lawyer. The allegation is about your purpose, and statements are a main way the state tries to prove purpose.
- Do not contact the person who made the report.
- Do not delete anything from your phone, computer or accounts.
- Gather and keep documents. Keep release conditions, any search warrant and any property receipt listing what was seized.
- Call a defense lawyer early. Arizona Sex Crime Lawyers defends only people accused of sexual offenses, including cases where the sex crime label comes from a special allegation. The firm’s attorneys include former prosecutors, former law enforcement officers, and former public defenders, led by Michael Tamou. Call (623) 777-3346 for a free, confidential consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Is sexual motivation a crime by itself?
No. It is a special allegation attached to another criminal charge. It has no felony or misdemeanor class of its own, but a finding can lead to court-ordered sex offender registration.
Does sexual gratification have to be the only reason for the crime?
No. Under A.R.S. § 13-118, sexual motivation means that one of the purposes of the crime was the defendant’s sexual gratification. The state does not have to prove it was the sole purpose.
Who decides whether the allegation is true?
The trier of fact decides and returns a special verdict. In a jury trial that is the jury. The standard is proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
Can the allegation be added to a sex crime charge?
The statute applies to criminal cases involving an offense other than a sexual offense. Charges that are already sexual offenses carry their own registration rules.
If the jury finds sexual motivation, is registration automatic?
No. Under A.R.S. § 13-3821, the judge may order registration for an offense with a finding of sexual motivation. The decision is made by the judge after the finding.
Sources
- A.R.S. § 13-118: who may file the allegation, the evidence required, the burden of proof, the special verdict and the definition of sexual motivation.
- A.R.S. § 13-3821: the mandatory registration list, the judge’s discretion after a sexual motivation finding, and the registration duties.
- A.R.S. § 13-905: the rule that a conviction with a sexual motivation finding cannot be set aside.
- A.R.S. § 36-3701: sexually motivated offenses that count as sexually violent offenses for civil commitment.
- State v. Harlow, 219 Ariz. 511 (Arizona Court of Appeals, Division Two, 2008): the allegation in an indictment, the verdict-form interrogatory, and a finding on a lesser offense.
- State v. Cruz, 252 Ariz. 411 (Arizona Court of Appeals, Division Two, 2022): an admission of sexual motivation in a plea agreement as a finding under § 13-118.