What does A.R.S. § 36-3701 say?
A.R.S. § 36-3701 defines a sexually violent person as someone who has ever been convicted of or found guilty but insane of a sexually violent offense, or was charged with one and determined incompetent to stand trial, and who has a mental disorder that makes the person likely to engage in acts of sexual violence.
Read A.R.S. § 36-3701 in fullWhat that means
In plain terms, Arizona can ask a court to keep some people in a treatment facility after their criminal case or sentence is over. Two things must both be true: the person has a case involving an offense the law lists as sexually violent, and the person has a mental disorder that makes future sexual violence likely. A conviction alone is not enough. This is a civil case, not a new criminal sentence.
Under the sexually violent person Arizona statutes, the state can ask a court to keep a person in a treatment facility, with no fixed end date, after a prison sentence is over. It can do that only if two things are both proved beyond a reasonable doubt: the person has a case involving an offense the law lists as “sexually violent”, and the person has a mental disorder that makes future sexual violence likely. This page is for people in Phoenix and the Valley who are deciding how to resolve a criminal case, and for families who have learned that a petition may be filed before a release date.
Who is a sexually violent person under A.R.S. § 36-3701?
A.R.S. § 36-3701 defines a sexually violent person (SVP) as a person who meets both of these conditions:
- The person has ever been convicted of or found guilty but insane of a sexually violent offense, or was charged with one and found incompetent to stand trial.
- The person has a mental disorder that makes the person likely to engage in acts of sexual violence.
“Mental disorder” has a specific meaning here: a paraphilia, personality disorder or conduct disorder, or a combination of them, that predisposes a person to commit sexual acts to such a degree that the person is a danger to the health and safety of others. A conviction alone is never enough. The second condition is a clinical question that each side addresses through expert evaluation.
The word “likely” sets a high bar. In In re Leon G., 204 Ariz. 15 (2002), the Arizona Supreme Court upheld the SVP law and read “likely” to mean “highly probable”, a standard it described as somewhat higher than “probable”. The state must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the person has a mental disorder that predisposes the person to commit sexual acts to a dangerous degree, and that the disorder makes it highly probable the person will engage in acts of sexual violence. The court said the law requires “much more than a finding of dangerousness”: the disorder, not a voluntary choice, must be what makes the person dangerous, and typical repeat offenders who choose to commit sexual violence fall outside the act. The court also directed trial judges to instruct juries on that requirement.
Which convictions count as sexually violent offenses?
| Category | Offenses |
|---|---|
| Listed sex offenses | Indecent exposure (§ 13-1402) to a person under 15; public sexual indecency to a minor (§ 13-1403); sexual conduct with a minor (§ 13-1405); sexual assault (§ 13-1406); molestation of a child (§ 13-1410); continuous sexual abuse of a child (§ 13-1417) |
| Violent offenses found to be sexually motivated | Second degree murder, first degree murder, assault, aggravated assault, unlawful imprisonment, kidnapping and first degree burglary, when a court determines beyond a reasonable doubt that the act was sexually motivated under § 13-118 |
| Preparatory offenses | Attempts, solicitations, facilitations and conspiracies to commit the above. These are incomplete or assisting versions of the listed crimes |
| Out-of-state and older offenses | An act in another jurisdiction that would be a sexually violent offense in Arizona, and comparable felony convictions under laws in effect before September 1, 1978 |
The second row is the reason a sexual motivation special allegation in a non-sex case matters so much. A finding of sexual motivation can turn an assault or burglary conviction into a qualifying offense, and the statute allows that determination to be made at sentencing or in the civil commitment proceedings themselves.
How does an SVP case start?
The process begins before release from custody.
- Referral. Under A.R.S. § 36-3702, an agency with jurisdiction over a person 18 or older who may be a sexually violent person must send a written request that a petition be filed to the county attorney or the attorney general, not more than 180 days and not less than 30 days before the person’s anticipated release. The agency supplies court documents, evaluation and treatment records, the person’s own account of the offenses, police reports, institutional records, and a final release report with a professional opinion completed within the preceding 120 days.
- Petition. Under A.R.S. § 36-3704, the county attorney, or the attorney general in some out-of-state cases, may file a petition in superior court alleging that the person is a sexually violent person. For a Valley case, that means the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office and Maricopa County Superior Court in Phoenix.
- Incompetency cases. Under A.R.S. § 13-4518, if a defendant is found incompetent to stand trial with no substantial probability of regaining competency within 21 months, and is charged with or has ever been convicted of or found guilty except insane for a sexually violent offense, the county attorney may ask for SVP screening. The court appoints a competent professional to report within 30 days, and the criminal case may not be dismissed until the report is provided and a hearing is held or a petition is filed.
Notice that the agency’s file includes the person’s own version of the offenses, along with group notes and progress notes from treatment. What a person says in treatment and in institutional interviews can end up in front of the SVP court.
What happens after the petition is filed?
| Step | Statute | Timing or standard |
|---|---|---|
| Judge decides whether probable cause exists; if so, orders detention in a licensed facility under the supervision of the superintendent of the Arizona state hospital | § 36-3705 | On filing of the petition |
| Respondent may request a probable cause hearing | § 36-3705 | Within ten days after service |
| Court gives notice of, and an opportunity to appear at, a probable cause hearing | § 36-3705 | Within 72 hours after detention |
| Evaluation by a competent professional, at county expense | § 36-3705 | If probable cause is reaffirmed or no hearing is requested |
| Trial | § 36-3706 | Within 120 days after the petition is filed, unless continued |
| Verdict | § 36-3707 | Beyond a reasonable doubt |
The “respondent” is the person named in the petition. A “competent professional” is an evaluator who is familiar with the SVP statutes and Arizona’s sex offender treatment programs and is approved by the superior court. At the probable cause hearing under A.R.S. § 36-3705, the person may present evidence, cross-examine witnesses and view and copy the court file. If the court finds no probable cause, it must dismiss the petition.
What rights does a person have at an SVP trial?
The case is civil, but several protections resemble a criminal trial:
- Counsel. The person is entitled to counsel at every proceeding, appointed if indigent.
- Jury. Under A.R.S. § 36-3706, the county attorney, the attorney general or the person named in the petition may request a jury trial. Otherwise the trial is to the court. The jury is not the twelve-person, unanimous jury of a serious criminal trial. In State ex rel. Romley v. Superior Court, 198 Ariz. 164 (App. 2000), the Arizona Court of Appeals held that because the case is civil, the jury consists of eight persons and the agreement of six or more is enough for a verdict, even though the standard of proof is beyond a reasonable doubt.
- Burden of proof. Under A.R.S. § 36-3707, the court or jury must determine beyond a reasonable doubt whether the person is a sexually violent person, and the state must prove any alleged sexual motivation beyond a reasonable doubt.
- An independent evaluator. Under A.R.S. § 36-3703, each party may select its own competent professional, and if the person is indigent the court must assist in retaining one.
Other rules can work against the person named in the petition. The Arizona Rules of Evidence and Rules of Civil Procedure apply, and the court may admit evidence of past sexual acts under § 13-1420, the same statute discussed on our page about evidence of other sexual acts. The judge may also continue the trial past the 120 days at either party’s request for good cause, or on the court’s own motion if the person will not be substantially prejudiced.
If the state meets its burden, the court either commits the person to the department of health services for placement in a licensed facility, or orders release to a less restrictive alternative (court-ordered treatment in a setting short of total confinement) if the conditions of A.R.S. § 36-3710 and § 36-3711 are met. Commitment lasts until the person’s mental disorder has so changed that the person would not be a threat to public safety. The facility is the Arizona Community Protection and Treatment Center (ACPTC), which the Arizona State Hospital’s annual report describes as located on the same grounds as the hospital. According to that report, it houses people awaiting an SVP trial, committed residents in full confinement who can leave the grounds only for court proceedings and medical appointments, and residents on a less restrictive alternative, who are monitored by GPS. If the state does not meet its burden, the court must order the person’s release.
How does a committed person get out?
There is no release date. The court’s jurisdiction continues until it discharges the person. There are two forms of release:
- Conditional release to a less restrictive alternative, under A.R.S. § 36-3709.
- Discharge, under A.R.S. § 36-3714.
A less restrictive alternative is not simple release. Before ordering it, the court must find under A.R.S. § 36-3711 that a qualified provider has presented a specific course of treatment and agreed to report to the court, that the person has housing secure enough to protect the community, with the housing provider’s written agreement, and that the person will comply with the provider, the court and supervision. Under A.R.S. § 36-3710, the court must also find that conditional release is in the person’s best interest and will adequately protect the community. The person must first undergo up to 90 days of inpatient evaluation at the state hospital. Outpatient treatment is required and may include monitoring by polygraph or plethysmograph, the provider reports to the court each month, and the court reviews the case within one year.
Either one can be reached in two ways. A petition can follow a determination by the superintendent or the director of the department of health services that the person’s mental disorder has so changed that the person is not likely to engage in acts of sexual violence. In that case the court must hold a hearing within 45 days. The person may also petition annually without that approval, and the director must give annual written notice of that right.
At the hearing, the burden stays on the state. It must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the mental disorder has not changed and that the person remains a danger to others and is likely to engage in acts of sexual violence. On a discharge petition, if the state does not meet that burden, the person must be discharged.
What people commonly get wrong about SVP commitment
- “Any sex offense conviction can lead to commitment.” Only the offenses in § 36-3701 qualify. The list of sex offenses there does not name, for example, sexual abuse under § 13-1404 or sexual exploitation of a minor under § 13-3553.
- “Only a sex crime conviction counts.” An assault, kidnapping or first degree burglary conviction qualifies if a court finds beyond a reasonable doubt that the act was sexually motivated.
- “Juvenile cases do not count.” The statute defines “conviction” to include a juvenile court order adjudicating a person delinquent for a sexually violent offense. The agency referral itself applies to a person who is at least 18.
- “Any mental health diagnosis is enough.” The definition is limited to a paraphilia, personality disorder or conduct disorder that predisposes the person to commit sexual acts to a dangerous degree, and the disorder must make future sexual violence likely.
- “If the agency misses the referral window, the case is over.” Section 36-3702 says an agency’s inability to meet the time requirements does not bar the county attorney or attorney general from filing a petition.
An example of how the process works
This is a hypothetical example, not a real case. Suppose a man is three months from finishing a prison sentence for molestation of a child, a listed offense. The department of corrections sends the Maricopa County Attorney a referral with his treatment records and a report from a professional who believes he has a paraphilia that makes him likely to reoffend. The county attorney files a petition. A judge finds probable cause, and on his release date he is moved to a licensed facility instead of going home. He has ten days from service to ask for a probable cause hearing, and a trial is due within 120 days. At trial, his own evaluator can dispute the diagnosis and the risk prediction, and the state must prove both conditions beyond a reasonable doubt. Compare a man finishing a sentence for sexual abuse of an adult under § 13-1404. That offense is not on the list, so if he has no other qualifying conviction, the first condition cannot be met, whatever an evaluator might say about him.
Limits and conditions written into the statutes
- Timing. The petition is filed before the person is released from confinement.
- Both conditions are required. A qualifying offense without the mental disorder, or a disorder without a qualifying offense, is not enough.
- Incompetency cases get an extra step. If the person was found incompetent to stand trial, the court must first hear evidence and find beyond a reasonable doubt that the person committed the acts charged before it considers commitment.
- Sexual assault of a spouse counts only if the offense was committed before August 12, 2005.
- A less restrictive alternative is possible at the outset, but only if the conditions in § 36-3710 and § 36-3711 are met.
- Challenges to facility conditions are hard. At a hearing about conditions of detention or treatment, the detained person must show that the facility’s actions have no reasonable basis in fact or law.
What a defense lawyer does about SVP exposure
- During the criminal case: identify whether a charge or a proposed plea is to a sexually violent offense, contest any sexual motivation allegation, and advise the client about this consequence before a plea is entered. A psychosexual evaluation may be obtained at this stage. Its purpose is a written report, by a qualified evaluator, that can show the accused is not sexually interested in the ages or the behavior alleged and is not the kind of person who acts that way. It may include a polygraph. The defense can use the report in negotiations with the prosecutor and at sentencing, and the same questions return in any later SVP case.
- At the petition stage: request the probable cause hearing within the ten days, cross-examine the state’s witnesses, and review the court file.
- At trial: retain an independent competent professional, challenge the state’s evaluation, the claimed mental disorder and the prediction of future violence, and decide whether to request a jury.
- After commitment: file annual petitions and hold the state to its burden.
What to do next
- If a criminal case is still open, ask your lawyer directly whether the charge or the plea being offered is to a sexually violent offense under § 36-3701, before anything is signed.
- If a family member is in custody and nearing release on a listed offense, ask a lawyer about SVP referral well before the release date. The referral window opens 180 days before release.
- If a petition has been served, act immediately. The request for a probable cause hearing must be filed within ten days after service.
- Gather and keep records: the judgment and sentencing paperwork, treatment and program completion records, and any prior evaluations.
- Do not speak with a state evaluator or investigator about the offense without first getting a lawyer’s advice.
- Call Arizona Sex Crime Lawyers at (623) 777-3346 for a free, confidential consultation. The firm defends only people accused of sexual offenses in Phoenix and the Valley.
Frequently asked questions
Is SVP commitment a second prison sentence?
Legally it is a civil commitment for treatment, not a criminal sentence. It is still confinement in a licensed facility with no fixed end date, which is why it should be treated as seriously as the criminal case.
Can someone be committed without ever being convicted?
Yes, in limited situations. The definition includes a person who was charged with a sexually violent offense and found incompetent to stand trial, and a person found guilty but insane. The state must still prove the mental disorder condition beyond a reasonable doubt.
How often can a committed person ask for release?
The person may petition annually for conditional release or discharge without the approval of the superintendent or the director. A petition that follows their favorable determination must be heard within 45 days.
Does a single indecent exposure conviction make someone a sexually violent person?
No. Indecent exposure to a person under 15 is a listed sexually violent offense, but the law also requires a mental disorder that makes the person likely to engage in acts of sexual violence. Both conditions must be proved.
Sources
- A.R.S. § 36-3701: definitions of sexually violent person, sexually violent offense, mental disorder, conviction, competent professional, and less restrictive alternative.
- A.R.S. § 36-3702: agency referral, timing, and the records sent with it.
- A.R.S. § 36-3703: each party’s right to a competent professional.
- A.R.S. § 36-3704: who files the petition, rules of evidence and procedure, right to counsel, continuing jurisdiction, and challenges to facility conditions.
- A.R.S. § 36-3705: probable cause, detention, hearing rights, and evaluation.
- A.R.S. § 36-3706: trial deadline and jury request.
- A.R.S. § 36-3707: burden of proof, commitment, release, and the extra findings in incompetency cases.
- A.R.S. § 36-3709 and A.R.S. § 36-3714: petitions for conditional release and discharge.
- State ex rel. Romley v. Superior Court, 198 Ariz. 164, 7 P.3d 970 (Arizona Court of Appeals, 2000): an eight-person jury, with six or more jurors sufficient for a verdict.
- A.R.S. § 36-3710 and A.R.S. § 36-3711: conditions and required findings for a less restrictive alternative.
- In re Leon G., 204 Ariz. 15, 59 P.3d 779 (Arizona Supreme Court, 2002): the SVP law upheld, and “likely” read to mean “highly probable”.
- Arizona State Hospital, Annual Report, State Fiscal Year 2022 (Arizona Department of Health Services): the Arizona Community Protection and Treatment Center and its types of residents.
- A.R.S. § 13-4518: SVP screening of defendants found incompetent to stand trial.
- A.R.S. § 13-118: the sexual motivation finding that can make a violent offense qualify, and A.R.S. § 13-1420: evidence of other sexual acts.
- Offense statutes named on this page: § 13-1402, § 13-1403, § 13-1404, § 13-1405, § 13-1406, § 13-1410, § 13-1417, and § 13-3553.