What is obscenity offenses in arizona in Arizona?
Arizona obscenity offenses are knowingly producing, selling, distributing or presenting an obscene item with knowledge of its character (A.R.S. § 13-3502), requiring a retailer to accept obscene items for resale or penalizing a refusal (A.R.S. § 13-3504), and operating an adult oriented business at a prohibited location or during prohibited hours (A.R.S. § 13-1422).
Read A.R.S. § 13-3502 in fullWhat that means
In plain terms, these laws regulate the business side of adult material, not what an adult keeps at home. Dealing in material that meets Arizona's three-part test for obscene is a felony. So is a supplier forcing a shop to carry it. Adult businesses must also stay a quarter mile from schools, homes and similar places and close overnight. Sexually explicit material is not automatically obscene.
Obscenity Offenses in Arizona is not on Arizona's Dangerous Crimes Against Children list in A.R.S. § 13-705. If it is charged together with an offense that is, the DCAC ranges apply to that count. See which offenses are covered.
If you own, manage or work for an adult store, club, theater or distribution business in the Phoenix area and police or inspectors are asking questions, one of three Arizona statutes may be involved. A.R.S. § 13-3502 makes it a class 5 felony to knowingly produce, sell or commercially present an obscene item. A.R.S. § 13-3504 makes it a class 5 felony to force a retailer to accept obscene items for resale. A.R.S. § 13-1422 makes it a class 1 misdemeanor to operate an adult oriented business too close to a school, home or similar place, or during required closing hours. Sexually explicit material is not automatically obscene, private possession is not covered, and none of the three is on Arizona’s mandatory sex offender registration list.
Which charge are you facing? The three statutes compared
| Statute | Conduct | Mental state in the text | Classification | Sex offender registration | Dangerous Crimes Against Children sentencing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A.R.S. § 13-3502, obscene items | Producing, publishing, selling, renting, lending, importing, commercially distributing or exhibiting an obscene item, possessing one with intent to do so, or presenting an obscene performance to the public or for consideration | Knowingly, and with knowledge of the character of the item | Class 5 felony | Not on the mandatory list in § 13-3821(A) | No |
| A.R.S. § 13-3504, coercing acceptance | Requiring a purchaser or consignee to take obscene items for resale as a condition of receiving publications, or denying a franchise or imposing a penalty (or threatening either) over a refusal or a return | None is named in the section | Class 5 felony | Not on the mandatory list in § 13-3821(A) | No |
| A.R.S. § 13-1422, adult oriented businesses | Locating an adult oriented business within one-fourth mile of a protected use, or keeping a listed adult business open during prohibited hours | None is named in the section | Class 1 misdemeanor, and each day is a separate offense | Not on the mandatory list. A judge has discretion under § 13-3821(C) because the statute is in chapter 14 | No |
The first two charges depend on the material being legally obscene. The third does not: it turns on what kind of business it is, where it sits, and when it is open.
How does Arizona obscenity law define obscene?
The definition is in A.R.S. § 13-3501 and applies to both § 13-3502 and § 13-3504. An item is obscene when all three of these are true:
- The average person, applying contemporary state standards, would find that the item, taken as a whole, appeals to the prurient interest.
- The average person, applying those standards, would find that it depicts or describes sexual activity, as the statute defines that term, in a patently offensive way.
- Taken as a whole, it lacks serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value.
“Contemporary state standards” is the statute’s phrase, and it is not a national test. In State v. Bartanen, 121 Ariz. 454 (1979), the Arizona Supreme Court, applying the same three-part wording in an earlier version of the statute, held that contemporary state standards govern both the prurient interest question and the patently offensive question. The court added that in actual practice a state standard is the standard of the community from which the jury is drawn.
If any one of the three parts is missing, the item is not obscene and the charge fails. “Sexual activity” is itself a defined term: patently offensive representations or descriptions of ultimate sexual acts, masturbation, excretory functions, sadomasochistic abuse, or lewd exhibition of the genitals. An “item” includes books, magazines, photographs, films, recordings, objects and live performances.
Producing, selling or presenting obscene items: A.R.S. § 13-3502
Under § 13-3502 it is a crime, with knowledge of the character of the item, to knowingly do any of the following:
- Print, copy, manufacture, prepare, produce or reproduce an obscene item for purposes of sale or commercial distribution.
- Publish, sell, rent, lend, transport or transmit in intrastate commerce, import or send into Arizona for sale or commercial distribution, or commercially distribute or exhibit an obscene item, or offer to do any of those things.
- Possess an obscene item with intent to sell, rent, lend, transport or commercially distribute it.
- Present or participate in presenting the live, recorded or exhibited performance of an obscene item to the public, or to an audience for consideration or commercial purpose.
What the state must prove
- The item was obscene under all three parts of the § 13-3501 definition.
- The defendant had knowledge of the character of the item.
- The defendant knowingly did one of the four listed acts.
“Knowledge of the character” is broader than it sounds. Section 13-3501 defines it as general knowledge or awareness, reason to know, or a belief or ground for belief that warrants further inspection, that the item depicts sexual activity, whether or not the person actually knew its specific contents. The state may prove it with direct or circumstantial evidence.
How obscenity is proved at trial
A.R.S. § 13-3510 says expert testimony or other ancillary evidence is not required to determine obscenity if the item itself has been placed in evidence. The item is treated as the best evidence of what it represents. The same section helps the defense in one situation: if a person relied on a film rating from the Motion Picture Association of America or an equivalent association, the rating and evidence of that reliance are admissible.
Penalty
The offense is a class 5 felony. Section 13-3502 sets no sentence of its own and does not itself require a prison term. The general ranges are in the sentencing section below.
Coercing acceptance of obscene articles: A.R.S. § 13-3504
This section is aimed at the supply side of the publications business, not at readers, viewers, or shops that simply sell adult material. It applies to any “person, firm, association or corporation” and prohibits two kinds of conduct:
- Tie-in sales. Requiring a purchaser or consignee, as a condition of a sale, allocation, consignment or delivery for resale of a paper, magazine, book, periodical or publication, to receive for resale another item that is obscene.
- Retaliation. Denying or threatening to deny a franchise, or imposing or threatening to impose a penalty, financial or otherwise, because a person failed or refused to accept such items or returned them.
What the state must prove
- The defendant imposed a condition of the first kind, or denied a franchise, imposed a penalty, or threatened either, as described in the second.
- For the second kind, the denial, penalty or threat was “by reason of” the refusal to accept the items or their return.
- The items were obscene under the § 13-3501 definition.
Unlike § 13-3502, this section does not name a mental state. It does not say what the defendant must have known about the items or the demand. Arizona’s general rule, in A.R.S. § 13-202(B), is that when a statute does not expressly prescribe a mental state, none is required and the offense is one of strict liability “unless the proscribed conduct necessarily involves a culpable mental state”. Whether requiring a retailer to take items, or penalizing a refusal, necessarily involves one is a legal question for the court, and it is one to raise early. The section also contains no exemptions or built-in defenses.
The evidence rule in § 13-3510 described above is not limited to § 13-3502. Its first sentence applies whenever obscenity has to be determined and the item is in evidence, and § 13-3504 sits in the same obscenity chapter.
Penalty
A violation is a class 5 felony, the same class as § 13-3502.
Adult oriented business location and hours: A.R.S. § 13-1422
This statute sets two rules. Neither requires proof that anything sold or shown was obscene.
The location rule
An adult oriented business may not be located within one-fourth mile of any of the following:
- a child care facility
- a private, public or charter school
- a public playground
- a public recreational facility
- a residence, meaning a permanent dwelling place
- a place of worship, meaning a structure where people regularly assemble for worship and that a reasonable person would recognize as one from its design, signs, or architectural or other features
Distance is measured in a straight line in all directions, from the nearest point on the property line of the business’s parcel to the nearest point on the property line of the protected parcel, without regard to structures or objects in between.
The hours rule
Seven kinds of business must close during set hours: adult arcades, adult bookstores or video stores, adult cabarets, adult motion picture theaters, adult theaters, escort agencies, and nude model studios.
| Day | Required closing period |
|---|---|
| Monday through Saturday | 1:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m. |
| Sunday | 1:00 a.m. to 12:00 noon |
Section 13-1422 defines adult cabaret, escort and escort agency itself. The other business types, and “adult oriented business”, take their meaning from A.R.S. § 11-811. In short form:
- Adult oriented business: adult arcades, adult bookstores or video stores, cabarets, adult live entertainment establishments, adult motion picture theaters, adult theaters, massage establishments that offer adult service, and nude model studios.
- Adult arcade: a place open to the public where coin-operated or electronically controlled machines show images involving specific sexual activities or specific anatomical areas to people in booths or viewing rooms.
- Adult bookstore or video store: a commercial establishment that, as one of its principal business purposes, sells or rents printed or visual material depicting or describing specific sexual activities or specific anatomical areas, or devices designed for use in connection with specific sexual activities. “Principal business purposes” means fifty percent or more of gross income comes from those items.
- Adult motion picture theater: a commercial establishment where films or similar reproductions characterized by specific sexual activities or specific anatomical areas are predominantly shown for any form of consideration.
- Adult theater: a theater or similar commercial establishment that predominantly features people who appear in a state of nudity, or live performances characterized by the exposure of specific anatomical areas or by specific sexual activities.
- Nude model studio: a place where a person who appears nude or displays specific anatomical areas is observed, drawn, photographed or otherwise depicted by people who pay. Licensed proprietary schools and colleges are excluded.
Section 11-811 also defines nudity, seminude, specific anatomical areas and specific sexual activities. The exact wording controls, and a business near the edge of a definition should have it read against the full text.
What the state must prove
- An adult oriented business was located within one-fourth mile of a listed protected use; or
- A listed adult business remained open during the prohibited hours.
The statute does not say which individuals answer for a violation, so whether the right person was charged can be an issue. Two general statutes fill part of the gap. Under A.R.S. § 13-306, a person is criminally liable for conduct he or she performs or causes to be performed in the name of or on behalf of an enterprise, as if it were done in the person’s own name. Under A.R.S. § 13-305, the enterprise itself commits a misdemeanor when an agent engages in the conduct within the scope of employment and on the enterprise’s behalf. Section 13-1422 names no mental state, so the § 13-202(B) rule described above applies to it as well.
Penalty and civil enforcement
A violation of either rule is a class 1 misdemeanor, the most serious misdemeanor class, and each day of violation is a separate offense. For a location violation only, the county attorney, or a citizen who lives in the county or city, may also sue to abate the violation and to enjoin it perpetually, meaning to obtain a court order that stops it permanently. That order can run against the person committing the violation and the owner, lessee or agent of the building. An order of that kind can close a business at that address.
Sentencing ranges, probation and time limits
| Question | § 13-3502 and § 13-3504 (class 5 felonies) | § 13-1422 (class 1 misdemeanor) |
|---|---|---|
| First-offense sentence | Prison: minimum 9 months, presumptive 1.5 years, maximum 2 years under A.R.S. § 13-702 | Jail: up to 6 months under A.R.S. § 13-707, for each day charged |
| Ordinary maximum probation term under A.R.S. § 13-902 | Three years | Three years |
| Lifetime probation rule in § 13-902(E) | Does not apply. It covers felonies in chapters 14 and 35.1, and these offenses are in the obscenity chapter | Does not apply. The rule covers felonies, and this is a misdemeanor |
| Time limit to charge under A.R.S. § 13-107 | Generally seven years from discovery | Generally one year from discovery |
The presumptive term is the sentence a judge starts from before weighing aggravating or mitigating circumstances. With at least two mitigating or two aggravating circumstances, the first-offense range for a class 5 felony widens to 6 months at the low end and 2.5 years at the high end. Prior felony convictions raise the range, and whether probation is actually available depends on prior convictions and other sentencing laws.
For a class 1 misdemeanor, the maximum fine for an individual is $2,500 under A.R.S. § 13-802. That limit does not apply to an enterprise. Under A.R.S. § 13-803, the maximum fine for an enterprise is $20,000 for a class 1 misdemeanor and $1,000,000 for a felony.
Injunctions and seizure of inventory
A criminal charge is not the only tool the state has against a business. Under A.R.S. § 13-3505, the county attorney or a city attorney may sue in superior court for an injunction against selling or distributing obscene material. The business is entitled to a trial within ten days after the issues are joined and a decision within ten days after trial. If an injunction is entered, the order directs the business to surrender the material to the sheriff to be seized and destroyed. Under A.R.S. § 13-3503, obscene material found in the possession of a person arrested for it is delivered to the magistrate, who, on finding it obscene, gives one copy to the county attorney and destroys the rest.
Registration and Dangerous Crimes Against Children
None of the three offenses is listed in A.R.S. § 13-3821(A), the mandatory registration list. The discretionary rule in § 13-3821(C) works differently for each group:
- § 13-1422. Subsection C lets the sentencing judge require registration for any violation of chapter 14, and § 13-1422 is in that chapter. For a location and hours offense that would be an unusual result, but it is a reason to treat a charge carefully. See sex offender registration in Arizona.
- § 13-3502 and § 13-3504. These are in the obscenity chapter, which subsection C does not name. Registration could come into play only through a separate finding of sexual motivation under A.R.S. § 13-118, which the state must prove beyond a reasonable doubt. See sexual motivation allegation.
None of the three is a dangerous crime against children under A.R.S. § 13-705, so the enhanced sentences described on our Dangerous Crimes Against Children page do not apply.
What people commonly get wrong about these laws
- “Sexually explicit means obscene.” It does not. All three parts of the definition must be met, and the first two are judged by the average person applying contemporary state standards.
- “Nudity alone can be obscene.” An obscene item must depict or describe sexual activity as § 13-3501 defines it. Nudity by itself is not on that list.
- “I never looked at it, so I did not know.” Under § 13-3502, knowledge of the character does not require knowing the specific contents. Reason to know, or grounds for belief that warrant further inspection, can be enough.
- “A film rating is a complete defense.” Section 13-3510 makes the rating and the person’s reliance on it admissible. It does not say that reliance ends the case.
- “A threat that was never carried out does not count.” Section 13-3504 covers threatening to deny a franchise or to impose a penalty, not just doing so.
- “The location and hours rules are zoning, not crime.” They are both. A violation of § 13-1422 is a class 1 misdemeanor, every day is a new offense, and it does not matter whether anything in the business is obscene.
- “We are far enough away by road.” Driving distance is not the test. The measurement is a straight line between property lines.
Example: one store, three statutes
This is a hypothetical example, not a real case. Suppose an undercover officer buys a video from an adult video store in Phoenix, and the owner and the part-time clerk who rang up the sale are both charged under § 13-3502. For each of them the state must prove that the video is obscene under all three parts of the definition, that the person had knowledge of its character, and that the person knowingly sold it. The owner who chose the inventory and the clerk who worked the register may be in very different positions on knowledge. If the video, taken as a whole, has serious artistic value, it is not obscene and the charge fails for both.
Now suppose the owner says the video came in a monthly bundle that the wholesaler required the store to take in order to keep receiving its other titles. That is the kind of tie-in § 13-3504 describes, and it is a charge against the wholesaler, not the store. It also depends on the bundled items being obscene. If the wholesaler only offered the bundle and the store was free to decline, no condition was imposed.
Finally, suppose the same store stayed open until 2:00 a.m. on five nights that week. Each night is a separate class 1 misdemeanor under § 13-1422, so the state could file five counts, whatever the answer on obscenity turns out to be.
Exceptions and limits written into the statutes
Section 13-3502
- Private possession. Possession is covered only with intent to sell, rent, lend, transport or commercially distribute.
- Production for private use. The production paragraph applies to items made for purposes of sale or commercial distribution.
- Private performances. The performance paragraph applies to a performance presented to the public, or to an audience for consideration or commercial purpose.
- Lending is included. The statute lists lending along with selling and renting, so the absence of a payment does not by itself take conduct outside it.
- Licensed broadcasts and telecasts. Under A.R.S. § 13-3511, the obscenity chapter does not apply to broadcasts or telecasts through facilities licensed under the federal communications act or under title 9, chapter 5, article 1.1 of the Arizona statutes. The exemption says nothing about websites or downloads.
Section 13-3504
- Resale transactions only. The tie-in rule covers a sale, allocation, consignment or delivery of publications for resale. It does not describe a sale to an ordinary customer.
- The penalty must be tied to the refusal or return. A franchise decision made for another reason is outside the retaliation rule.
Section 13-1422
- A protected use that arrives later. A business lawfully operating in conformity with the statute does not violate the location rule if a school, residence or other protected use later locates within one-fourth mile of it.
- Liquor-licensed establishments. The definition of adult cabaret excludes any establishment licensed under the liquor laws (title 4). That exclusion matters for the hours rule, which lists “adult cabaret”. The location rule uses the broader term “adult oriented business”, and the § 11-811 definition of that term includes “cabarets”, defined there as adult oriented businesses licensed to serve alcohol. A liquor license therefore does not by itself take a club outside the location rule.
- Only listed businesses. The hours rule covers the seven listed types and no others.
- Local ordinances. Counties and cities may enact their own ordinances on where adult businesses locate, and hours ordinances that are at least as restrictive as the state rule. Complying with the state statute does not settle what a city requires.
- Civil suits are for location only. The abatement and injunction lawsuit applies to location violations. The hours rule is enforced by criminal charge.
Material involving children is outside all of this. It is prosecuted under different and far more serious laws, such as sexual exploitation of a minor and furnishing harmful items to minors. A related display offense is covered on our page on public display of explicit sexual materials.
How these cases start and where they are heard in Phoenix
A case may begin with a complaint from a customer, neighbor, retailer or franchise holder, an undercover purchase, a licensing inspection, or a police visit after closing time. Valley police departments and the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office investigate, and investigators may look at inventory, invoices, contracts, emails and delivery records.
Charges under § 13-3502 and § 13-3504 are felonies. The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office decides whether to charge, and the case is filed in Maricopa County Superior Court in downtown Phoenix, whichever Valley city the business is in. A felony case there usually moves from an initial appearance to a grand jury indictment, an arraignment, a series of pretrial conferences, and trial.
A charge under § 13-1422 is a misdemeanor and does not follow that felony path. Under A.R.S. § 22-402 and A.R.S. § 22-301, a state-law misdemeanor committed inside a city can be filed by a city officer in that city’s municipal court. Otherwise it is heard in the justice court for the precinct where it happened, unless it is charged together with a felony. A civil abatement or injunction action over location is a separate lawsuit. An inspection can also lead to other charges, such as keeping a house of prostitution, some of which are felonies.
Defenses to obscenity and adult business charges
- The item is not obscene. This applies to § 13-3502 and § 13-3504. Serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value defeats the charge, as does a failure of either of the other two parts of the definition.
- No knowledge of the character of the item. Under § 13-3502, a clerk or shipper with no reason to know what an item depicts lacks the required knowledge.
- No commercial purpose. Section 13-3502 targets sale, distribution, and paid or public presentation.
- No condition was imposed, or there was a legitimate business reason. Under § 13-3504, offering material is different from requiring a retailer to take it, and a franchise decision or penalty may have had nothing to do with refused or returned items.
- The business is not a covered business, the distance is wrong, or the business was there first. Under § 13-1422, the definitions are specific, and the measurement, whether the nearby property is actually a protected use, and which use arrived first can all be contested.
- The business was closed. Staff cleaning or closing out after hours is different from being open to customers.
- The wrong person was charged. In a company, the state must prove which person sold the item, made the demand or threat, or was responsible for the location or hours.
- Reliance on a rating. Evidence of reliance on a film rating is admissible under § 13-3510.
- Unlawful search or seizure. Seizures of inventory and business records can be challenged.
- Constitutional challenges. Free expression challenges are possible but have limits. In Center for Fair Public Policy v. Maricopa County, 336 F.3d 1153 (9th Cir. 2003), the federal appeals court rejected a First Amendment challenge to the closing-hours rule in § 13-1422, treating it as a regulation aimed at the secondary effects of adult businesses and not at their content. One judge dissented. Whether a different challenge is available on your facts is a question to review with a lawyer.
Because these are business charges, a psychosexual evaluation matters only in limited places: where the state files a sexual motivation allegation, where a judge is deciding whether to order registration for a § 13-1422 violation, or at sentencing. It is a written report by a qualified evaluator that can show the accused is not sexually interested in the behavior alleged and is not the kind of person who acts that way. It may include a polygraph, and the defense can use it in negotiations and at sentencing.
What to do next if your business is cited or investigated
- Do not speak with police, investigators or inspectors about the allegation without a lawyer. That applies to owners, managers and employees alike.
- Do not contact or confront the person who complained, whether that is a customer, a neighbor, a retailer or a franchise holder.
- Do not delete, alter or discard anything. Keep inventory, sales and point-of-sale records, emails, texts, order systems, camera and alarm logs, and staff schedules as they are.
- Gather and keep documents. For an obscenity charge: purchase invoices, distributor catalogs, distribution and franchise agreements, return records, and any rating information you relied on. For a location or hours charge: licenses and permits, the lease or deed, a parcel map or survey, proof of the date the business opened, and anything showing when the nearby school, home or other use arrived. Keep any paperwork police or inspectors left with you.
- Call Arizona Sex Crime Lawyers at (623) 777-3346 for a free, confidential consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Is it illegal to own adult material in Arizona?
A.R.S. § 13-3502 does not make simple private possession a crime. It reaches possession only when it is coupled with intent to sell, rent, lend, transport or commercially distribute an item that meets the legal definition of obscene.
Who decides whether something is obscene?
The trier of fact, meaning the judge or jury deciding the case, applying the three-part definition in A.R.S. § 13-3501. The first two parts are judged from the viewpoint of the average person applying contemporary state standards. No expert witness is required once the item is in evidence, and the defense can present evidence on the value of the work taken as a whole.
Can an employee be charged, or only the owner?
Section 13-3502 applies to any person who knowingly does a listed act with knowledge of the character of the item. An employee who sells or exhibits an item can be charged, but the state must prove that employee’s own knowledge. Section 13-1422 does not say which individuals are responsible for a location or hours violation.
Does the obscenity charge apply to live performances?
Yes. Presenting or participating in presenting an obscene performance to the public, or to an audience for consideration or commercial purpose, is covered by § 13-3502. The performance must still meet all three parts of the definition of obscene.
Is selling adult magazines illegal in Arizona?
Not by itself. Section 13-3502 applies only to items that meet the legal definition of obscene, which is narrower than sexually explicit. Section 13-3504 addresses a supplier forcing a retailer to accept obscene items or punishing a refusal, not the retailer’s ordinary sales.
How close can an adult business be to a school in Arizona?
Under A.R.S. § 13-1422, an adult oriented business may not be located within one-fourth mile of a school. The same distance applies to child care facilities, public playgrounds, public recreational facilities, residences and places of worship. One-fourth mile is 1,320 feet, measured in a straight line between property lines.
What time do adult businesses have to close in Arizona?
The seven listed kinds of adult business must be closed from 1:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m. Monday through Saturday, and from 1:00 a.m. until noon on Sunday. Each day a business stays open in violation is a separate offense. A city or county ordinance can be stricter.
Can a neighbor take legal action against an adult business?
Yes, for a location violation. Section 13-1422 allows the county attorney, or a citizen who lives in the county or city, to sue to abate and enjoin the violation. That civil case is separate from any criminal charge, and it is not available for an hours violation.
Sources
Every legal statement on this page was checked against the official statute text published by the Arizona Legislature. Statutes change, so confirm the current version before relying on it.
- A.R.S. § 13-3502: the four ways the obscene items offense is committed, the knowledge requirement, and the class 5 felony classification
- A.R.S. § 13-3504: the tie-in and retaliation rules, who the section applies to, and the class 5 felony classification
- A.R.S. § 13-1422: the location and hours rules, measurement, the later-arriving exception, local ordinances, civil enforcement, definitions, and the class 1 misdemeanor classification
- A.R.S. § 13-3501: the three-part definition of obscene and the definitions of item, sexual activity and knowledge of the character
- A.R.S. § 13-3510: the rule that expert testimony is not required and the rule on film ratings
- A.R.S. § 13-702: the first-offense prison range for a class 5 felony and the meaning of a presumptive term
- A.R.S. § 13-707: the six-month maximum jail term for a class 1 misdemeanor
- A.R.S. § 13-802: the $2,500 maximum fine for an individual and the exclusion of enterprises from that limit
- A.R.S. § 13-902: the three-year ordinary probation terms and the offenses covered by the lifetime probation rule
- A.R.S. § 13-107: the seven-year and one-year time limits to charge
- A.R.S. § 13-705: the list of dangerous crimes against children, which includes none of these offenses
- A.R.S. § 13-3821: the mandatory registration list in subsection A and the judge’s discretion in subsection C
- A.R.S. § 13-118: the sexual motivation special allegation and its burden of proof
- A.R.S. § 11-811: the definitions of adult oriented business, adult arcade, adult bookstore or video store, adult motion picture theater, adult theater, cabaret and nude model studio
- A.R.S. § 13-202: how a statute that names no mental state is read
- A.R.S. § 13-305 and A.R.S. § 13-306: criminal liability of an enterprise and of an individual acting for one
- A.R.S. § 13-803: maximum fines for an enterprise
- A.R.S. § 13-3503 and A.R.S. § 13-3505: seizure of obscene material and the civil injunction action
- A.R.S. § 13-3511: the exemption for licensed broadcasts and telecasts
- A.R.S. § 22-301 and A.R.S. § 22-402: which courts hear misdemeanors
- State v. Bartanen, 121 Ariz. 454, 591 P.2d 546 (Arizona Supreme Court 1979): contemporary state standards apply to both prurient interest and patent offensiveness
- Center for Fair Public Policy v. Maricopa County, 336 F.3d 1153 (U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit 2003): the closing-hours rule in § 13-1422 upheld against a First Amendment challenge