What is duty to report obscene items in Arizona?
A.R.S. § 13-3509 requires a person who is asked to record, film, photograph, develop or duplicate any visual or print medium depicting sexual activity, whether or not for compensation, to immediately report the request to a municipal or county peace officer. Knowingly failing to make that report is a criminal offense.
Read A.R.S. § 13-3509 in fullWhat that means
In plain terms, if someone asks you to film, photograph, print, develop or copy material that shows sexual activity, the law requires you to tell a city or county law enforcement officer right away. This applies whether or not you would be paid. The report has to say who asked, if you know, and what they asked for. Knowingly failing to report the request is a crime.
Duty to Report Obscene Items is not on Arizona's Dangerous Crimes Against Children list in A.R.S. § 13-705. If it is charged together with an offense that is, the DCAC ranges apply to that count. See which offenses are covered.
If someone asks you to record, film, photograph, develop or copy material that depicts sexual activity, A.R.S. § 13-3509 requires you to report the request immediately to a city or county peace officer, whether or not you would be paid. Knowingly failing to report is a class 6 felony. This duty to report obscene items applies to photographers, videographers, print and copy shops, and anyone else in the Phoenix area who receives such a request.
What does A.R.S. § 13-3509 require?
Under § 13-3509, a person who is asked to record, film, photograph, develop or duplicate any visual or print medium depicting sexual activity, whether or not for compensation, must immediately report the request to a municipal or county peace officer. The report must include:
- The name or names of the person, persons or business making the request, if known.
- A description of what was requested.
Knowingly failing to report, or to cause a report to be made, is a crime. The statute sits in Arizona’s obscenity chapter, and “sexual activity” is a defined term in A.R.S. § 13-3501.
What the state must prove
- The defendant was asked to record, film, photograph, develop or duplicate a visual or print medium depicting sexual activity.
- The defendant knowingly failed to immediately report the request, or cause a report to be made, to a municipal or county peace officer.
Penalties and registration
| Question | Answer from the statutes |
|---|---|
| Class | Class 6 felony |
| Dangerous crime against children | No. The offense is not on the list in A.R.S. § 13-705. See dangerous crimes against children |
| Sex offender registration | Not listed in A.R.S. § 13-3821(A) |
| Ordinary probation term | Up to three years for a class 6 felony under A.R.S. § 13-902 |
| Time limit to charge | Seven years from discovery under A.R.S. § 13-107. A class 6 felony keeps that period even if later designated a misdemeanor |
For a first felony offense, the general class 6 range in A.R.S. § 13-702 is a presumptive term of 1 year, a minimum of 6 months and a maximum of 1.5 years, with a mitigated term of 0.33 years and an aggravated term of 2 years. The presumptive term is the standard sentence a judge starts from, and the mitigated and aggravated terms are the lowest and highest available when mitigating or aggravating circumstances are found.
A class 6 felony can end as a misdemeanor. Under A.R.S. § 13-604, if the offense is not a dangerous offense and the court believes a felony sentence would be unduly harsh, given the crime and the person’s history and character, it may enter the conviction as a class 1 misdemeanor. It may instead place the person on probation and leave the offense undesignated, and it must designate the offense a misdemeanor when probation is successfully completed. Until then the offense is treated as a felony for purposes such as firearm rights and use as a prior conviction. This option is not available to a person with two or more prior felony convictions. A prosecutor can also file the charge as a misdemeanor at the outset.
A failure to report charge may surface during an investigation of the material itself, where the main charges may be sexual exploitation of a minor or producing or selling obscene items. Those carry much heavier consequences, so what a person says about a “request” needs care. A separate statute covers failure to report child abuse by mandatory reporters.
What people get wrong about the duty to report
- “It only applies to material involving minors.” The text of § 13-3509 states no age. It applies to a request involving any visual or print medium depicting sexual activity.
- “Sexual activity means any nudity or sex scene.” It is a defined term. § 13-3501 defines sexual activity as patently offensive representations or descriptions of ultimate sexual acts, masturbation, excretory functions, sadomasochistic abuse and lewd exhibition of the genitals. Nudity is defined separately in the same section. Material outside the definition does not trigger the duty.
- “Telling my manager, or the website, is enough.” The report must go to a municipal or county peace officer. The statute is met if you report or “cause a report to be made”, so passing the request up the chain helps only if a report to law enforcement is actually made.
Example: a request at a print shop
This is a hypothetical example, not a real case. Suppose a customer brings a flash drive to a Mesa print shop and asks an employee to duplicate a video. The employee sees that it depicts sexual activity as the law defines it, refuses the job, and tells no one.
On the face of the statute, the duty arose when the employee was asked, and refusing did not end it. The question for the state would be whether the failure to report was knowing. If the employee had instead told the manager, and the manager called Mesa police that day with the customer’s name and a description of the request, the employee could point to the words “or cause a report to be made”.
Limits and conditions in § 13-3509
- A request and a knowing failure. The duty starts with being asked, and only a knowing failure to report is a crime. Both points are covered under defenses below.
- Names only “if known”. The report must describe what was requested. It must name the person or business that asked only if that is known.
- No listed exemptions. The section lists no exemption for any profession, business or type of customer.
How these cases play out in Phoenix
One way these cases can start is that police from a Valley city or the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office find images or video during another case and trace them back to whoever filmed, printed or copied them. That person is then interviewed, sometimes as a witness and sometimes as a suspect, and it is not always clear which. Anything said in that interview can be used later.
The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office makes the charging decision. Because the offense is a felony, it is filed in Maricopa County Superior Court in downtown Phoenix. That is true whether the business or arrest was in Tempe, Peoria, Gilbert, Goodyear or anywhere else in the Valley. The case is not heard in that city’s court.
Defenses
- No request was made. The duty is triggered by being asked. Finding material, or receiving it without a request, is a different situation.
- The material did not depict sexual activity as defined. The definition in § 13-3501 controls, not a detective’s opinion.
- Not knowing. The failure must be knowing. A person who never saw the content, or did not understand what was being requested, lacks that mental state.
- A report was made. The statute is satisfied by reporting or causing a report to be made. Records of a call, an email, or a supervisor’s report matter.
- Unlawful search or improperly obtained statements. Evidence taken from a business or device without lawful authority can be suppressed.
A psychosexual evaluation is a weaker fit for a reporting charge, but it can matter if the state alleges a sexual motive or the case reaches sentencing. It is a report, by a qualified evaluator, that can show the person is not sexually interested in the behavior alleged and is not the kind of person who acts that way. It may include a polygraph, and the defense can use it in negotiations and at sentencing.
What to do next
If you have just received a request like this, the statute’s instruction is to report it immediately to city police or the sheriff’s office. A lawyer can help you make that report promptly and keep proof that you made it.
If detectives have contacted you about a past request:
- Do not answer questions without a lawyer, even if you are told you are only a witness.
- Do not contact the person who made the request.
- Do not delete, copy or forward the material, the order, or any messages about it.
- Keep work orders, invoices, emails and texts, and any record of a report you or a supervisor made, including the date and who took it.
Arizona Sex Crime Lawyers offers a free, confidential consultation at (623) 777-3346.
Frequently asked questions
Does it matter that I was not paid?
No. The statute applies whether or not the request was for compensation. A favor for a friend is treated the same as a paid job.
Who do I report to?
The statute says a municipal or county peace officer. In the Phoenix area that means a city police department or the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office.
How fast is “immediately”?
The statute uses the word “immediately” and does not give a number of hours or days. The safe reading is to report without delay.
If I refused the job, do I still have to report?
The duty as written is triggered by being asked, not by agreeing. Refusing the request does not, on the face of the statute, remove the duty to report it.
Sources
Each section below was read in its official text on the Arizona Legislature’s website. Statutes change, so check the current version or ask a lawyer before relying on any of them.
- A.R.S. § 13-3509: the duty to report, what the report must contain, and the class 6 felony for a knowing violation
- A.R.S. § 13-3501: definitions of sexual activity, ultimate sexual acts and nudity
- A.R.S. § 13-702: first-offense prison range for a class 6 felony
- A.R.S. § 13-902: ordinary probation term for a class 6 felony
- A.R.S. § 13-705: list of dangerous crimes against children, which does not include this offense
- A.R.S. § 13-3821: mandatory registration list, which does not include this offense
- A.R.S. § 13-604: when a court or prosecutor may treat a class 6 felony as a class 1 misdemeanor
- A.R.S. § 13-107: seven-year time limit, including for a class 6 felony later designated a misdemeanor