What is obscene telephone communications to minors in Arizona?
Under A.R.S. § 13-3512, an obscene telephone communication to a minor is knowingly making by telephone, directly or by a recording device, any obscene or indecent communication for commercial purposes to a person under eighteen years of age. It is unlawful regardless of whether the maker of the communication placed the call.
Read A.R.S. § 13-3512 in fullWhat that means
In plain terms, this law is aimed at phone services run as a business, not at private calls. It makes it a crime to knowingly deliver obscene or indecent sexual talk, live or recorded, over the phone for a business purpose to someone under 18. It does not matter who dialed. A private call between two people with no business purpose does not fit this law, though other laws may apply.
Obscene Telephone Communications to Minors is not on Arizona's Dangerous Crimes Against Children list in A.R.S. § 13-705. If it is charged together with an offense that is, the DCAC ranges apply to that count. See which offenses are covered.
This charge is aimed at phone services run as a business, not at private calls between two people. Under A.R.S. § 13-3512, knowingly making an obscene or indecent telephone communication, live or recorded, for commercial purposes to a person under 18 is a class 4 felony. If you or your business has been contacted by police in the Phoenix area about obscene telephone communications to minors, start with the commercial purpose requirement, because it decides whether the statute applies at all.
What are obscene telephone communications to minors under A.R.S. § 13-3512?
It is unlawful to knowingly make by telephone, directly or by a recording device, any obscene or indecent communication for commercial purposes to a person under 18. The communication is unlawful regardless of whether the maker placed the call. The state must prove:
- The defendant knowingly made an obscene or indecent communication by means of a telephone, directly or by recording device.
- The communication was for commercial purposes.
- The recipient was under 18 years of age.
The word obscene is defined in A.R.S. § 13-3501. An item is obscene when the average person applying contemporary state standards would find that, taken as a whole, it appeals to the prurient interest, it depicts or describes sexual activity in a patently offensive way, and it lacks serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value. Neither § 13-3512 nor § 13-3501 defines indecent or commercial purposes.
What people commonly get wrong about this statute
- “Any sexual phone call with a minor falls under this law.” The statute requires a commercial purpose. A private call with no commercial purpose does not meet the second element, although other statutes may apply depending on what was said.
- “The business is safe if the minor was the one who called.” The statute says the communication is unlawful regardless of whether the maker placed the call.
- “A recording is not a communication to anyone.” The statute covers a communication made directly or by a recording device.
- “It covers texts and online chats.” The statute speaks of a communication made by means of a telephone. It does not mention text messages or internet messaging. Sexual material sent by direct message is addressed by a different law, covered on our page about furnishing harmful items to minors.
An example of the commercial purpose element
This is a hypothetical example, not a real case. Suppose a company runs a pay-per-minute adult phone line. A 16-year-old dials the number and hears a recorded explicit message. The service is a business, the message was delivered by a recording device, and it does not matter that the caller dialed. The contested questions would be whether the message was obscene or indecent, and what the word knowingly requires the state to prove about the caller’s age. On that second question two rules pull in different directions. A.R.S. § 13-202 says a mental state written into a statute applies to each element unless a contrary legislative purpose plainly appears. But in State v. Gomez (2019), the Arizona Court of Appeals collected decisions under other statutes holding that the state did not have to prove the defendant knew a child’s age, quoting an earlier case: “When the legislature intends that the mens rea apply to the status of the victim, it says so explicitly.” Neither authority involved § 13-3512.
By contrast, suppose two people have a sexual conversation by phone with no business or payment involved. Whatever other statute might apply, the commercial purpose element of § 13-3512 is missing.
Penalties and registration
| Question | Answer under the statutes |
|---|---|
| Classification | Class 4 felony |
| Sentencing range | First offense under § 13-702: 1.5 years minimum, 2.5 years presumptive, 3 years maximum. The presumptive term is the sentence the judge starts from. Section 13-3512 does not contain a clause barring probation, and under § 13-902 probation for a class 4 felony may last up to four years. A person sentenced as a repetitive offender under § 13-703 is not eligible for probation |
| Dangerous crime against children | No |
| Mandatory sex offender registration | No. The offense is not listed in § 13-3821(A) |
Although registration is not mandatory, A.R.S. § 13-3821 allows a judge to order registration for an offense that carries a finding of sexual motivation. Section 13-3512 is in chapter 35 of the criminal code, the obscenity chapter. The judge’s wider power to order registration without that finding covers only chapters 14 and 35.1. Our page on the sexual motivation special allegation explains how prosecutors raise that issue.
Limits and conditions in the statute
- Commercial purposes only. Without that element the statute does not apply.
- The age line is 18. The recipient must be under 18.
- Mistake about age is not clearly covered. Section 13-3501 excuses an honest mistake about a minor’s age after a reasonable bona fide attempt to ascertain it, but that language names § 13-3506, § 13-3506.01 and § 13-3507, not § 13-3512. Whether it reaches this offense is a legal question.
- Prior convictions. With a historical prior felony conviction, meaning an earlier felony that counts for repeat-offender sentencing, the range under A.R.S. § 13-703 is 3, 4.5 and 6 years. With two or more it is 8, 10 and 12 years. A person sentenced under § 13-703 is not eligible for probation.
How this differs from related charges
Sexual communication with a minor that is not commercial may be charged under other statutes:
- Offering or soliciting sexual conduct with a minor is luring a minor for sexual exploitation, a class 3 felony.
- Commercial production or sale of obscene material is covered on our page about producing or selling obscene items.
How these cases start in Phoenix
A case may begin with a parent’s complaint after finding charges on a phone bill or hearing a call, or with an investigation of a business. The police department that takes the report, or the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office, investigates. Phone records, billing records and recordings may be obtained by subpoena or warrant.
The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office decides whether to charge. Felony sex crime charges from every Valley city are filed in Maricopa County Superior Court in downtown Phoenix, whether the report was made in Chandler, Peoria, Tempe or elsewhere in the metro area. After an initial appearance, the County Attorney usually obtains an indictment, a formal charge issued by a grand jury. The case then moves to a not guilty arraignment, pretrial conferences and a trial date, and those dates are commonly moved.
Defenses
- No commercial purpose. A private call with no business behind it does not meet the second element.
- The communication was not obscene or indecent. The obscenity test in § 13-3501 looks at the communication as a whole and applies contemporary state standards.
- Lack of knowledge. The communication must be made knowingly.
- Unlawful search and unreliable statements. Records seizures and interviews are reviewed for legal defects.
A psychosexual evaluation is a weaker fit for a business-based charge like this one, but it can matter if the state files a sexual motivation allegation or the case reaches sentencing: it is a report by a qualified evaluator, which may include a polygraph, that can show the accused is not sexually interested in minors and is not the kind of person who acts that way, and the defense can use it in negotiations and at sentencing.
What to do next if you or your business is contacted
- Do not give a statement to police without a lawyer. That applies to owners, managers and employees.
- Do not contact the minor or the family who made the complaint.
- Do not delete or alter anything. Leave recordings, scripts, billing data and call logs as they are.
- Gather and keep documents. Keep any subpoena or warrant you received, along with records showing how the service was operated and billed and any steps used to check callers’ ages.
- Call a defense lawyer early. Arizona Sex Crime Lawyers defends only people accused of sexual offenses in the Phoenix metro area. Call (623) 777-3346 for a free, confidential consultation with our attorneys.
Frequently asked questions
Does this law cover a private sexual phone call with a 17 year old?
A.R.S. § 13-3512 requires that the communication be for commercial purposes. A private call without a commercial purpose does not meet that element, although other statutes may apply depending on what was said.
Does it matter who placed the call?
No. The statute says the communication is unlawful regardless of whether the maker placed the call. A service that a minor calls into is treated the same as one that calls the minor.
Is a recorded message covered?
Yes. The statute covers a communication made by telephone directly or by a recording device.
What if the caller lied about being an adult?
Section 13-3501 excuses an honest mistake about a minor’s age after a reasonable bona fide attempt to ascertain it. That provision names other sections, not § 13-3512, so whether it applies here is a question for a defense lawyer.
Sources
- A.R.S. § 13-3512: the offense, the commercial purpose element, the age of 18, the rule on who placed the call and the class 4 classification.
- A.R.S. § 13-3501: the definition of obscene and the mistake of age language.
- A.R.S. § 13-3506.01: the separate statute for sexual material sent by direct internet message.
- A.R.S. § 13-702 and A.R.S. § 13-703: general class 4 felony ranges and the probation bar for repeat offenders.
- A.R.S. § 13-3821: the mandatory registration list and registration after a sexual motivation finding.
- Arizona Revised Statutes, Title 13 index: § 13-3512 is in chapter 35, obscenity.
- A.R.S. § 13-902: the probation period for a class 4 felony.
- A.R.S. § 13-202: how a mental state written into a statute applies to its elements.
- State v. Gomez, No. 1 CA-CR 17-0774 (Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One, Feb. 26, 2019): Arizona decisions on proof of knowledge of a child’s age.