What is surreptitious photographing and recording in Arizona?
Under A.R.S. § 13-3019, surreptitious recording is knowingly photographing, filming, recording or secretly viewing another person without consent, either where the person has a reasonable expectation of privacy and is nude, undressing or similarly exposed, or in a manner that captures the person's genitalia, buttock or female breast not otherwise visible to the public.
Read A.R.S. § 13-3019 in fullWhat that means
In plain terms, it is a crime to secretly take pictures or video of someone, or secretly watch them, without that person agreeing, when they are in a private place like a bathroom or bedroom and are undressed, using the toilet or having sex. It also covers shots up a skirt or down a shirt. It is a crime even if the recording is never shared, and sharing it is a separate offense.
Surreptitious Photographing and Recording is not on Arizona's Dangerous Crimes Against Children list in A.R.S. § 13-705. If it is charged together with an offense that is, the DCAC ranges apply to that count. See which offenses are covered.
Surreptitious recording in Arizona is a felony under A.R.S. § 13-3019. It means knowingly photographing, filming or secretly watching another person without consent, either in a private place while the person is undressed or in a way that captures intimate body parts. It is a crime even if nothing was ever shared and even if there was no sexual purpose. The basic offense is a class 5 felony. In the Phoenix area these cases can arise from bathrooms, bedrooms, gym locker rooms, dressing rooms, rentals, and phones held under a skirt in a store.
What is surreptitious recording under Arizona law?
Section 13-3019 makes it unlawful to knowingly photograph, videotape, film, digitally record or secretly view another person without that person’s consent, with or without a device, in either of two situations:
- The person is in a restroom, bathroom, locker room, bedroom or other place with a reasonable expectation of privacy, and is urinating, defecating, dressing, undressing, nude, or involved in sexual intercourse or sexual contact.
- The recording or viewing is done in a manner that directly or indirectly captures or allows the viewing of the person’s genitalia, buttock or female breast, whether clothed or unclothed, that is not otherwise visible to the public.
The statute also makes it unlawful to disclose, display, distribute or publish a recording made in violation of the section without the consent or knowledge of the person depicted.
What must the state prove?
- The defendant knowingly photographed, videotaped, filmed, digitally recorded or secretly viewed another person.
- The other person did not consent.
- Either the person was in a location with a reasonable expectation of privacy while urinating, defecating, dressing, undressing, nude or involved in sexual intercourse or sexual contact, or the viewing or recording captured the person’s genitalia, buttock or female breast not otherwise visible to the public.
- For the disclosure offense instead: the defendant disclosed, displayed, distributed or published a recording made in violation of the section without the consent or knowledge of the person depicted.
What are the penalties for surreptitious recording?
| Conduct | Class |
|---|---|
| Photographing, recording or viewing with a device | Class 5 felony |
| Disclosing, displaying, distributing or publishing a recording made in violation of the section | Class 5 felony |
| Violation that does not involve the use of a device, first violation | Class 6 felony |
| Violation that does not involve the use of a device, second or subsequent violation | Class 5 felony |
| Disclosing, displaying, distributing or publishing a recording when the person depicted is recognizable | Class 4 felony |
The prison range for each class depends on the person’s record. For a first felony offense, the general ranges in A.R.S. § 13-702 apply. The presumptive term is the standard sentence a judge starts from. The mitigated and aggravated terms are the lowest and highest sentences available when mitigating or aggravating circumstances are found.
- Class 4 felony: presumptive 2.5 years, mitigated 1 year, aggravated 3.75 years.
- Class 5 felony: presumptive 1.5 years, mitigated 6 months, aggravated 2.5 years.
- Class 6 felony: presumptive 1 year, mitigated 0.33 years, aggravated 2 years.
Prior felony convictions raise the ranges under Arizona’s repetitive offender statute, A.R.S. § 13-703. Ordinary probation terms under A.R.S. § 13-902 run up to three years for a class 5 or 6 felony and up to four years for a class 4 felony.
Surreptitious recording is not on the list of dangerous crimes against children in A.R.S. § 13-705, so that sentencing scheme does not apply to it.
If a recording depicts a minor, expect the state to look at other statutes as well, including sexual exploitation of a minor, which carries far heavier penalties.
Does a conviction require sex offender registration?
Not automatically. Surreptitious recording is not on the mandatory list in A.R.S. § 13-3821(A). There is still a path to the registry. Under A.R.S. § 13-118, the prosecutor can file a special allegation that an offense other than a sexual offense was committed with a sexual motivation, meaning that one of the purposes of the crime was the defendant’s sexual gratification. If that is proven beyond a reasonable doubt, the judge may order registration.
Fighting that allegation can be as important as fighting the charge. A psychosexual evaluation is one tool for that. It is done to produce a written report by a qualified evaluator. The report can show that the person is not sexually interested in the behavior alleged and is not the kind of person who acts that way, and the evaluation may include a polygraph. The defense can use the report in negotiations with the prosecutor and at sentencing. Our page on the sexual motivation special allegation explains how it works, and sex offender registration in Arizona explains what registration means in daily life.
What do people get wrong about surreptitious recording?
- “There was nothing sexual about it, so it is not a crime.” The offense does not require a sexual purpose. That is the main difference between this statute and voyeurism under A.R.S. § 13-1424, which requires that the privacy invasion be for the purpose of sexual stimulation.
- “It only covers cameras.” The statute applies “with or without a device”, so secretly watching is covered. The lack of a device lowers a first violation to a class 6 felony. It does not remove the offense.
- “The person was clothed and out in public.” The second theory covers capturing a person’s genitalia, buttock or female breast “whether clothed or unclothed” when it is not otherwise visible to the public, and that paragraph names no particular location. A phone angled under clothing in a store aisle can fit it.
- “I only passed along a video someone else made.” The disclosure subsection is written about the recording, not about who made it. It covers disclosing, displaying, distributing or publishing a recording “made in violation” of the section without the consent or knowledge of the person depicted. How that applies to a person who did not know how a recording was made is a question to raise with a lawyer.
Example: one hidden camera, three possible outcomes
This is a hypothetical example, not a real case. Suppose a homeowner hides a small camera in a guest bathroom and records a houseguest undressing, without the guest’s consent.
Making the recording fits the first theory: a bathroom, a person undressing, no consent, a knowing act. Because a device was used, that is a class 5 felony even if the file is never opened again. If the homeowner later sends the clip to a friend and the guest can be recognized, the disclosure is a separate class 4 felony.
Now change the facts so there is no camera, and the homeowner watches through a gap in the door. The conduct is still covered, as a class 6 felony for a first violation.
What exemptions and limits does § 13-3019 contain?
The statute lists four exemptions. It does not apply to:
- Recording for security purposes, if notice of the recording equipment is clearly posted in the location and the location is one in which the person has a reasonable expectation of privacy.
- Recording by correctional officials for security reasons, or in connection with an investigation of alleged misconduct on the premises of a jail or prison.
- Recording by law enforcement officers pursuant to an otherwise lawful investigation.
- The use of a child monitoring device as defined in A.R.S. § 13-3001.
Outside those exemptions, the limits are in the elements themselves: the other person’s consent, the requirement of a knowing act, and, for the second theory, the words “not otherwise visible to the public”. Each is discussed under defenses below.
There is also a time limit. Under A.R.S. § 13-107, the state generally has seven years to file a felony like this one, measured from when it discovered or should have discovered the offense. See the statute of limitations for sex crimes.
How do these cases start in Phoenix?
A case can start when someone finds a camera or a phone: a roommate, a guest, a coworker, a store employee. Police from the city where it happened, or the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office, take the device and apply for a search warrant. A forensic examination of phones, computers and cloud accounts follows, and it can take months. Some people learn they are suspects only when detectives arrive with a warrant or ask for “their side of the story.”
The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office makes the charging decision. Because the offense is a felony, the case is filed in Maricopa County Superior Court in downtown Phoenix. It does not matter whether the arrest was made in Tempe, Gilbert, Surprise, Avondale or another Valley city. The case is not filed in that city’s court.
After arrest, there is an initial appearance within about a day. Almost everyone charged with a sex offense in Maricopa County is given a bond. The main exception is a person who was on felony probation when arrested. The bond is usually high, and ankle monitoring is typically required as a condition of release, along with an order to have no contact with the accuser. The judge can also order no contact with minors. A defense lawyer can ask the judge to lower the bond or change the conditions. A status conference and preliminary hearing are set but are usually vacated because the County Attorney indicts through a grand jury. Then come the not guilty arraignment and four dates: the Initial Pretrial Conference, the Comprehensive Pretrial Conference, the Final Trial Management Conference, and trial. Those dates are commonly moved.
What defenses apply to a surreptitious recording charge?
- Consent. Lack of consent is an element. Messages, prior recordings made together, and the relationship between the people can all bear on it.
- No reasonable expectation of privacy. Where the person was and what they were doing both matter. A place open to view is different from a bathroom or bedroom.
- The recording does not show what the statute requires. If the person was not in one of the listed states, and no listed body part “not otherwise visible to the public” was captured, the element is missing.
- Not knowing. The recording must be made knowingly. A security camera, a doorbell camera, or a phone left recording by accident raises a real question.
- Identity. A device in a shared home or workplace does not prove who placed it or who used it.
- Unlawful search. Phones and accounts are protected. A warrant that is too broad, or a search without one, can lead to suppression.
- Statements. What was said to detectives, and how the interview was conducted, can be open to challenge.
- Recognizability. For the class 4 felony, the person depicted must be recognizable.
Our attorneys retain experts where the case calls for them. In a recording case that can include a digital forensic examiner, who can test when a file was made, on which device, and who had access to it.
Where the evidence is strong, a defense lawyer may still be able to limit the number of counts, contest a sexual motivation allegation, or work toward a resolution that avoids registration. No outcome can be guaranteed.
What should you do next if police took your devices or called you?
- Do not talk to detectives without a lawyer, including when they ask for “your side of the story”.
- Do not contact the person who reported you.
- Do not delete files, wipe devices, or close cloud or social media accounts.
- Do not view, copy or send the recordings to anyone.
- Keep the search warrant, the property receipt for anything seized, and any other paperwork from the officers.
- Write down for your lawyer which devices and accounts exist and who else had access to them and to the home or workplace.
Our attorneys defend only sex offense cases in the Phoenix area. Call (623) 777-3346 for a free, confidential consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Is it a crime if I never showed the recording to anyone?
Yes. Making the recording, or secretly viewing, is the offense. Sharing a recording of a recognizable person is a separate and more serious class 4 felony.
Can I be charged for recording in my own home?
Yes. The statute protects a person in a bathroom, bedroom or other place where they have a reasonable expectation of privacy, and it does not matter who owns the home. Cameras in guest rooms, rentals and shared bathrooms can lead to charges.
What if I only looked and did not record?
The statute covers secret viewing with or without a device. Without a device it is a class 6 felony for a first violation and a class 5 felony for a second or subsequent violation.
Is this the same law that covers recording phone calls?
No. A.R.S. § 13-3019 is about photographing, filming or viewing people in private situations or capturing intimate body parts. Recording conversations is governed by other statutes. Under A.R.S. § 13-3005, it is a class 5 felony to intentionally intercept a call or electronic communication to which the person is not a party, or a conversation at which the person is not present, without the consent of a party. A.R.S. § 13-3012 exempts an interception made with the consent of a party to the communication or of a person who is present during it.
The police took my phone months ago and I have heard nothing. Is the case over?
Not necessarily. Forensic examinations take time, and the state generally has seven years to file a felony under A.R.S. § 13-107. This waiting period is a good time to speak with a defense lawyer, before any charging decision is made.
Sources
Each section below was read in its official text on the Arizona Legislature’s website. Statutes change, so check the current version or ask a lawyer before relying on any of them.
- A.R.S. § 13-3019: the two recording and viewing theories, the disclosure offense, the four exemptions, and the class 4, 5 and 6 felony classifications
- A.R.S. § 13-1424: voyeurism, for the sexual stimulation requirement that § 13-3019 does not have
- A.R.S. § 13-702: first-offense prison ranges for class 4, 5 and 6 felonies
- A.R.S. § 13-703: repetitive offender sentencing for people with prior felony convictions
- A.R.S. § 13-902: ordinary probation terms
- A.R.S. § 13-705: list of dangerous crimes against children, which does not include this offense
- A.R.S. § 13-3821: mandatory registration list, and the judge’s power to order registration after a sexual motivation finding
- A.R.S. § 13-118: the sexual motivation special allegation and its definition
- A.R.S. § 13-107: seven-year time limit for felonies
- A.R.S. § 13-3001: definition of a child monitoring device, for the fourth exemption
- A.R.S. § 13-3005 and A.R.S. § 13-3012: interception of calls and conversations, and the exemption for consent of a party